Work

The role of language in deductive reasoning: evidence from global aphasia

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The human species is marked by sophisticated cognitive capacities and by the possession of language. Within the philosophical and cognitive sciences there is a debate regarding the role of language in human reasoning. One claim states that grammar (combinatorial rules) is necessary for various forms of reasoning; as a result, significant language impairment is expected to disrupt logical reasoning. This project will provide new evidence to the debate by exploring performance in a unique sample of people – those with severe/global aphasia (language impairment following brain-injury), and examining whether a human mind, with little access to language resources, can apply deductive reasoning rules. To this end, we will be using complex Sudoku grids, which require the application of deduction rules (e.g. modus ponens). To address potential criticism that retention of these abilities is a result of functional reorganisation, we will utilise fMRI, comparing brain activations of aphasic and neurotypical participants.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7154793563
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10