Work

Management Control and Mental Health:Implications for Psychological Safety and Employee Stress

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Work-related stress, poor well-being, disengagement, and general dissatisfaction peaked during the COVID-19 crisis but continue to characterize the everyday experience of a large share of the global workforce.This development reflects a broader mental health crisis in workplaces today (Gallup, 2025; WHO, 2024).Beyond its consequences for individual employees, this trend also poses substantial risks to organizations through higher turnover, absenteeism, and productivity loss, as well as to society as a whole (Hassard et al., 2018).This dissertation examines the influence and role of management controls in this mental health crisis.Management controls are designed to guide employee behavior and actions and therefore have far-reaching implications for employees' everyday work experiences.While management control research has traditionally focused on how controls influence motivation, decision-making, and goal alignment, considerably less attention has been paid to their implications for employee mental health (Bedford et al., 2022).The dissertation conceptualizes mental health as multidimensional.Rather than viewing mental health solely as an absence of stress, it also encompasses the presence of mental resources that enable employees to cope with everyday demands.Accordingly, the dissertation examines mental health through two complementary lenses: clinical stress, representing severe and clinically relevant outcomes of work-related strain, and psychological safety, defined as a shared perception that interpersonal risk-taking is safe and supported, representing a key psychological resource in organizations.Thus, this dissertation examines how management controls relate to psychological safety and employee clinical stress and the implications of these relationships for both employees and organizations.To address these questions, the dissertation draws on two complementary datasets.The first combines survey data on management control practices with administrative medical register data capturing clinically diagnosed stress outcomes, estimated as prescribed medication for stress-related symptoms and stress-related therapy.The second dataset consists of survey data on management control practices and psychological safety, linked to five years of financial performance records.Based on these datasets, the dissertation comprises five empirical papers, each examining a specific management control mechanism in interaction with other controls or contextual factors.The overarching premise is that management controls rarely operate in isolation; rather, their effects depend critically on how they are combined and enacted within V organizational contexts.Drawing on psychological safety theory and occupational health perspectives, the dissertation examines how management control practices shape employee mental health as a complement to, rather than a substitute for, organizational performance and expectations.Paper 1 examines the interdependence between budget targets and budgeting processes.The findings show that ambitious budget targets enhance both learning and financial performance only when embedded in psychologically safe budgeting processes.Neither targets nor processes are sufficient in isolation.This paper establishes that the mental health and performance consequences of management controls depend critically on their social and relational context, showing that when budgeting processes are characterized by respectful dialogue and freedom from fear, ambitious targets can drive both organizational learning and performance.Paper 2 investigates how psychologically safe environments emerge from management controls themselves.Focusing on costing system complexity, the paper shows that more complex systems enhance organizations' ability to differentiate between types of failure.In turn, the detection of intelligent failures, failures that arise from experimentation or situations in which outcomes are uncertain, increases psychological safety.Lastly, increased psychological safety strengthens organizational resilience.The paper illustrates how management controls can create social conditions that support both employee mental health and organizational performance.Paper 3 shifts focus on clinical stress and examines the underexplored macro-function of budget planning.The findings indicate that budget planning in isolation increases clinical stress, but under conditions of high environmental uncertainty, planning instead reduces stress by providing structure and clarity.Importantly, the study illustrates that the mental health consequences of management controls depend not only on internal configurations but also on external contextual conditions.Paper 4 focuses on dysfunctional budgeting behaviors such as gaming, myopia, and manipulation and how performance evaluation systems trigger stress associated with such behavior.The findings show that neither dysfunctional budget climates nor performance evaluation alone generate clinical stress, as employees can typically cope with these pressures.However, when they co-occur, they substantially increase stress and, indirectly, employee turnover.These findings highlight how specific combinations of controls and VI organizational climates can escalate stress and produce significant employee and organizational consequences.Paper 5 examines how a reduction in budget detail affects clinical stress.The findings show that reductions in budget detail lower clinical stress both directly and in interaction with budget planning and budget-based performance evaluation.For the dissertation, this paper provides a counter-narrative to the prevailing assumption that more detailed budgets necessarily improve control and provide stability, showing instead that excessive detail can undermine employee mental health and that simplification can be beneficial.Taken together, the five papers demonstrate from multiple perspectives how combinations of management controls and contextual conditions shape employee mental health.The dissertation shows that management controls can be designed to prioritize employee wellbeing without compromising organizational performance.
Institution: Aarhus University
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7155023308
Cites: 336
Cited by:
Related to: 10