Work

Fragmented Solidarities: on Female Survivors of Domestic Violence with a Migration Background in the Netherlands

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Still, there is a lack of detailed, in-depth research on the intersection of factors related to gender and cultural background, including migration history, particularly within the field of Dutch social work.Moreover, social work literature identifies gender, cultural, and migration background as identity traits vital in understanding risk dynamics, professional engagement, and the design of tailored interventions (Mshweshwe, 2020;Wachter et al., 2022;Green et al., 2024).In the Dutch context, this intersection is particularly significant for women who arrive as first-generation migrants, who also occupy an additional vulnerable position due to their residence status (de Hart et al., 2022).Migration-related factors-such as insecure residency status, language barriers, dependency on a spouse for legal and 1.3.Gendered Cultural Expectations and Domestic Violence "Yeah, for my daughters too, I believe my culture is not feminist.My mother, but also others, don't believe in feminism.But I stayed quiet when they told me about things.Why should I tell them [daughters] how to live in the future?But I will tell them the good things and bad things [about my culture]."-Mary, survivor In this quote, Mary, a survivor of domestic violence from a Pakistani background and nationality, shares how she grew up with cultural and social expectations for women.These expectations are one reason Mary, like Yasmina and other women I interviewed, remained with her partner initially, despite being subject to both physical and emotional violence in the relationship.While these expectations play a role in women's decision-making, I will also explore how cultural expectations influence other factors, such as family support, policies and their implementation, and the identity and actions of social workers in their client assistance.I thus research how these expectations influence the solidarity shown towards survivors by families, policies, and social workers.The way in which policies are created and enacted by state-funded professionals can lead to specific outcomes for women experiencing domestic violence.Consequently, institutional solidarity is the analytical perspective I use to determine whether this policy leads to supportive results or not.The concept aligns with Bayertz's (1999) notion of Civic Solidarity, which underscores the routine and institutionalized provision of support.However, for clarity, I adopt a more specific definition from Arts and Gelissen (2001), who describe institutional solidarity as support provided to citizens in need through formal mechanisms, such as laws and policies, and by professionals facilitating their implementation.This definition is foregrounded in Chapter Two, as it highlights not only the structural 1.4.3.Social Workers and Domestic Violence "My social worker said: "Saawi, I fear you won't be alive anymore.Or I think you will return to the shelter".And she was right, because I am back in the shelter."-Saawi, survivor As Saawi mentions in the quote above, when I interviewed her, it was not her first time in the shelter.The previous time, her social worker expressed concerns about her considering returning to her partner, which is what Saawi eventually did.When women arrive at shelters or seek assistance following experiences of domestic violence, they often come into close contact with social workers.These professionals have various roles, providing not only practical support but also emotional and 1.5.Research Design and Methods This thesis adopts a qualitative approach, focusing on the experiences of both female survivors and social workers, and draws on a narrative research framework.Hence, the research aims to offer an indepth analysis of how stories are interconnected, as well as how they are socially produced and contextualised (Creswell et al., 2007).In total, 47 participants were interviewed: 10 survivors and 37 social workers, including 3 in managerial positions.The reason for exploring the perspectives of both 1.5.2.Social Workers Data Collection After conducting narrative interviews, I started semi-structured interviews with the social workers.This method typically consists of a conversation between the researcher and participant, with flexibility in asking questions.While the interview had a specific aim, it was still possible to collect open-ended data Chapter 2The Role of Dutch Policies in Women with Migration Backgrounds' Decisions to Leave a Violent Relationship
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7155668388
Cites: 48
Cited by:
Related to: 10