Work

Investigating the Healthy Migrant Effect: Revealing Immigrant Mortality Trends in 19th Century Upstate New York through Census Records

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: I examine mortality patterns in the context of increasing migration in late 19th-century upstate New York. Research on the Healthy Migrant Effect seeks to explain why immigrants experience lower age-adjusted mortality compared to US-born individuals despite social and economic factors often associated with increased mortality. This phenomenon has predominantly been studied in contemporary populations but has only rarely been studied in historical populations. I assess trends in immigrant mortality using data for n = 3850 individuals from Federal and State census records c. 1850-1880 for the cities of Syracuse and Rochester in New York State. I use Kaplan-Meier survival analyses and Cox Proportional Hazards analysis to assess differences in survivorship between 1) Foreign and US-born individuals, 2) places of birth, 3) cities, 4) sexes, and 5) years. I find significantly higher survivorship for all immigrant groups in comparison to individuals born in New York State. However, those born in the United States outside of New York have higher survivorship compared to most immigrant groups. Among foreign-born individuals, those born in France have the highest survivorship while those born in Canada the lowest. Females have lower survivorship than males when looking at ages 10 to 60, but above 60 they have higher survivorship than males. In Rochester , the difference in survivorship between US-born and foreign-born individuals is significant, but it is not significant in Syracuse. Foreign-born individuals have significantly higher survivorship in census years 1870, 1875, and 1880, while US-born individuals have significantly higher survivorship in 1855. The survivorship results suggest that healthy migrant effect was at work during the 19th century, though the magnitude of the effect depended on factors such as place of birth, sex, city, and year of death.
Language: English
Subfield: Demography
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7159741128
Cites: 66
Cited by:
Related to: 10