Nature, Nurture, and Musicality: Genetic and Environmental Influences on Musical Perception and Engagement in Early Adolescence
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: The present study utilized the Colorado Adoption Project (CAP) to examine the genetic and environmental influences on musicality in early adolescence. Musicality is the culmination of both perceptual and behavioral music skills. The primary sample consisted of N = 633 children (47.40% female) from 428 families. Sibling analyses were restricted to one pair per household to ensure a balanced sample, yielding 94 nonadoptive and 88 adoptive pairs. Principal component analysis identified four primary factors: Ability, Engagement, Instruction, and Fluency. The results indicated that objective musical perception at age 12 correlated significantly with self-perceived Ability and Engagement, while Instruction and Fluency showed no significant relationships. Genetic predispositions were the primary drivers of Engagement and Instruction, and shared environmental influences were largely negligible across most measures. Given that these data were collected during the “pre-digital” era, the late 1990s, the findings reflect a period when children’s musical exposure was largely shaped by their immediate home and community rather than self-directed digital access. Future research should investigate whether modern access to social media and streaming platforms has amplified musical autonomy and whether this alters the dynamics between genetic predispositions and environmental influences observed in the present study.
Author: Peifer, Kathleen Blake
Institution: University of Colorado Boulder
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7160005009
