A Preliminary Examination of Whether Collaborative Governance Can Be Both Effective and Legitimate: Political Control as a Stress Test
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article offers a preliminary inquiry into whether collaborative governance can reconcile two demands: effective governance through innovation and democratic legitimacy grounded in representative institutions. Earlier studies of collaborative governance have often treated it as a largely value-neutral problem-solving tool. In contrast, this article focuses on the political role of parliaments and elected politicians as a “stress test” for innovation produced in collaborative arenas. To develop this argument, the article first highlights strategic management as the function to set and realize public value within collaborative governance̶ by defining problems, setting priorities, and aligning goals and actors. It then argues that both strategic management and collaborative governance tend to contain an elite-biased structure, which can weaken legitimacy and make collaborative innovation vulnerable in contexts of political polarization. From this perspective, the article emphasizes the need to embed collaborative governance within the frameworks of representative democracy so that collaborative outcomes can withstand contestation and sustain broader acceptance. It therefore examines how political steering and intervention may serve as the key mechanism linking collaborative governance to representative democracy. In doing so, it discusses the possibility that such steering can function as a stress test that transforms elite-driven innovation into socially accepted and more robust innovation. Finally, the article presents three propositions to guide future empirical analysis.
Author: 宇野原, 将貴
Language: Japanese
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7161092429
