Work

Making meaning of adaptation under a changing climate: Unpacking the assumptions underpinning how adaptation is known and experienced in coastal settings

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Despite growing efforts, coastal adaptation remains fragmented and insufficient in addressing the vulnerabilities of those most affected. These shortcomings are not only technical but political, shaped by competing ideas about what counts as adaptation and whom it serves. Although there is growing recognition of the need to understand the various ways adaptation is known and experienced, empirical work remains limited, especially work that critically examines the assumptions shaping these understandings and their implications for just and effective practice.This thesis addresses this gap by revealing how coastal adaptation is constructed across research, policy, and lived experience, and what consequences emerge when these constructions meet in practice. It focuses on the Caribbean Small Island Developing States (SIDS), with Barbados as the empirical focus, where climate vulnerability is acute and adaptation is a central policy priority. Grounded in critical constructivism and employing social imaginaries, risk, and temporalities as analytical lenses, I first examine the foundational assumptions shaping understandings of adaptation in research and policy, and how they relate to one another. I then explore how adaptation is understood by people who live and work along the coastline of Barbados, how these meanings relate to stabilized understandings, and lastly, what consequences emerge when these collide in practice. The analysis is developed across three interrelated papers: Paper I is a systematic literature review of how adaptive capacity is understood in indicator-based assessments of coastal systems; Paper II analyses how adaptation is imagined in policy in Barbados; and Paper III examines how islanders living or working in coastal areas make sense of coastal change and adaptation interventions.The findings show that coastal adaptation is constructed in increasingly sophisticated ways across research and policy. Yet persistent assumptions about risk, what adaptation should achieve, and how change unfolds over time can leave structural and political conditions underexamined. These understandings, however, are not totalising. Meanings grounded in lived experience are broader, shaped by social and climatic rhythms, understandings of nature as an active force, and notions of risk rooted in direct experience, everyday demands, and religious beliefs. When adaptation is reduced to a single interpretation, practice becomes constrained, not only by neglecting what people value, but by creating conditions in which maladaptation becomes more likely, and the uneven distribution of benefits and burdens is obscured. By clarifying how adaptation meanings are constructed across diverse perspectives, this thesis shows that coastal adaptation, especially in Caribbean SIDS, is deeply normative and political. It makes visible where different understandings diverge, align, or reshape one another, while opening space to redefine what adaptation means. This more nuanced understanding supports the reflexive approaches needed for more transformative adaptation in the region.
Institution: Lund University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7161371177
Cites: 255
Cited by:
Related to: 10