Work

E-participation in urban planning from a power perspective

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Urban planning and the associated public participation are undergoing a profound digital transformation. Digital public participation, namely e-participation, presents opportunities and challenges to planning practices. A substantial body of literature has demonstrated that e-participation tools (EPTs) can enhance the diversity of participatory methods, enable the collection of higher-quality data, and facilitate more efficient processing of the collected data by planners and researchers. However, existing research on EPTs has predominantly focused on the usefulness of digital tools, while paying limited attention to the development process of EPTs and the decision-making during development and adoption. Inspired by the theory of social construction of technology (SCOT), I argue that the process of e-participation should begin with the development of EPTs, and that decisions made at this phase may influence subsequent phases and ultimately shape the outcomes of e-participation. Accordingly, I conceptualised the e-participation process as comprising three phases: EPTs development, EPTs adoption, and EPTs implementation. I then examined one key issue within each phase through three articles. The aims were to develop a more in-depth understanding of e-participation processes and to identify potential problems and challenges that the digitalisation of public participation may pose for both participation and urban planning. Although power was not initially a central focus of the research, its influence became increasingly apparent across the three phases of the e-participation studies. This led me to recognise that a power perspective could serve as an interpretative lens to better understand the observations from my e-participation studies and to reveal underlying challenges embedded in prevailing modes of e-participation. Consequently, this dissertation addresses the following research question: What insights can be gained by re-examining studies of e-participation in urban planning from a power perspective? To answer this question, I first developed my power perspective, drawing on Steven Lukes’ three-dimensional theory of power and Mark Haugaard’s four-dimensional theory of power. I then employed this power perspective to re-examine the three articles on the respective phases of e-participation and to interpret their findings. The re-examination reveals that different actors interact with and shape the e-participation process through different power dynamics. These actors include EPT developers, development funders, planners, governments, and the public. EPT developers and development funders enter the power arena of urban planning in response to the demand for EPTs generated by e-participation and exercise their agency to shape the development of these tools. Planners, when confronted with the digitalisation of public participation, are constrained by their digital skills and access to information about available EPTs. Governments may seek to control the role of technology in public participation by shaping planning ideologies. Members of the public possess a degree of freedom in selecting EPTs and can develop their power through the use of EPTs such as social media. Methodologically, this research demonstrates the potential of the Lukesian-Haugaardian power perspective as an interpretive tool for re-examining e-participation studies. In practice, it calls for attention not only to the proactive inclusion of public participation in the development of EPTs, but also to structural factors, including power relations embedded in participatory processes, funding sources, and the dissemination of technology and information.
Author: Tan, Xunran
Language: English
Subfield: Urban Studies
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7162222268
Cites: 219
Cited by:
Related to: 10