The Relationship Between Black Students' Sense of Belonging and Their Persistence Within a Hispanic Serving Predominantly White Institution
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Sense of belonging can make or break the experiences of students within higher education, particularly those from underrepresented racial backgrounds in predominantly white institutional environments (Gopalan & Brady, 2020). It is through this sense of belonging that underrepresented students can develop greater persistence and motivation to continue and complete college (Fan et al., 2021). Through a mixed-methods approach using surveys and interviews, this study examined the relationship between Black students’ sense of belonging and persistence within a Hispanic Serving Institution that is also a predominantly white institution in the U.S. Southwest. Survey data from 238 Black undergraduate students was analyzed using confirmatory factor analysis and structural equation modeling to examine relationships between institutional belonging predictors and persistence outcomes. Quantitative findings indicated that two domains of sense of belonging, University Affiliation and University Support and Acceptance were the strongest predictors of persistence. Qualitative findings revealed that belonging was often cultivated through affinity-based communities rather than institutional structures, while institutional support was frequently perceived as performative. Participants also described persisting despite limited belonging, drawing on identity-based motivation and resistance. Integrated findings positioned belonging as a multidimensional construct shaped by institutional climate, representation, and sociopolitical context, with implications for institutional leadership and practice. This study contributes to the literature on student success by offering an equity-focused examination of Black students’ sense of belonging and persistence within Hispanic-Serving Institutions that also function as predominantly white institutions. By drawing on both quantitative and qualitative findings, the study highlights the ways in which institutional environments are shaped through leadership, policy, and everyday practice work to influence students’ experiences of belonging and their ability to persist. The findings extend existing understandings of belonging by emphasizing the importance of sustained, intentional, and coordinated institutional efforts, rather than symbolic or compliance-based approaches to equity. Additionally, this study provides practical contributions by identifying key areas for institutional action, including professional development, policy alignment, resource allocation, and ongoing engagement with Black students. Collectively, this research reinforces that fostering Black student belonging and persistence requires shared institutional responsibility and intentional action across multiple levels of the institution.
Author: Ferrell, Brianna
Institution: University of Arizona
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7162477535
