Year: 2024
Type: other
Abstract: ZfE | JSCA 149 (2024) unreachable, problematic and desirable; it is an elusive, but powerful notion, deeply engrained in the idea of science, which orients people's actions towards particular goals.Studying people's varied attempts to universalize or localize knowledge in the name of science -for political, ethical, or pragmatic purposes -offers relevant insights into how people imagine, create, justify or call into question often unequal social structures.It also reveals, as many of the contributions in this issue show, the hopeful visions scientists and citizen-scientists pursue in striving to build better futures.This special issue, then, speaks to a key theme in contemporary anthropological debate, namely the politics of knowledge and the complex quest for epistemic justice in an unequal world.Although science has been disputed since its inception, these contestations have gained a new dynamic in recent years as disparate actors from across the political spectrum have fundamentally called into question the status of science and its claims to universality.Central to these interventions are often critical reflections on 'whose science' produces what kind of knowledge, where, and for whom.While climate change sceptics and Covid-19 deniers have recently been most vocal in their critique of 'mainstream science', postcolonial critics have long diagnosed scientific institutions and ideologies as both unequal and biased.They argue that knowledge produced under these conditions cannot possibly have universal relevance for everyone, everywhere, given that the paradigmatic premises of universality remain largely unquestioned and are inherently bound up with notions of 'Western modernity'.At the same time, scientific approaches remain a compelling and normative force in people's ways of thinking, acting and feeling in the world.Demands are high for policy-makers worldwide to 'follow the science', for instance, in the context of climate change or during the pandemic.Here, many people are dissatisfied that governments are not taking the far-reaching relevance of scientific advice seriously enough.In the face of globally interconnected crises, injustices and existential threats, the idea of universally applicable standards continues to hold out the promises of equality, justice and survival.Between scepticism and aspiration, there are numerous suggestions and initiatives for re-thinking and re-situating what scientific universality could or should do.While recent media representations often suggest the radically opposed positions of those who celebrate and those who reject science or science-related truth-claims, in this special issue we offer a nuanced perspective on the diverse and shifting debates on the role, status and imagined possibilities of scientific knowledge in different social, geographical and epistemic contexts.We investigate mobilizations of universality with, for, and against science in fields as varied as astronomy, biomedicine, psychology, artificial intelligence, genetics, conservation ecology and environmentalism.Following well-established criticisms of science's claims to truth, universality and impartiality -prominent, among others, in the field of STS and in the history and anthropology of science (e.g.Franklin 1995; Haraway 1988;Harding 1991; Latour and Woolgar 1986; Martin 1998; Mol 2003) -we start from the assumption that what is seen as the universality of science in fact moves through, and is modified in, different contexts.Scientific knowledge is never absolute; rather, it is contingent and relational,
Source: MPG.PuRe (Max Planck Society)
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Reduced inequalities
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7163480876
