Work

Lack of value pluralism in legislation hampers Living in Harmony with Waters

Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This paper presents the first cross-jurisdictional legal analysis that systematically maps how water plural values are encoded in water law and assesses their legal feasibility. We argue that these are necessary steps for determining whether a legal system has the foundations to support pluralistic water-governance paradigms capable of moving beyond the instrumental and technocratic approaches that have dominated to date and have proven inadequate to address global water challenges. Existing frameworks, including IWRM, have narrowed the value of water to exchange values and assumed that human interference with nature can be managed through incremental adjustments (for example, correcting externalities or deploying technological fixes), thereby constraining their capacity to deliver water sustainability. As an alternative, “Living in Harmony with Nature” has gained traction as a vision that foregrounds value pluralism; however, it can only shape freshwater outcomes if it is translated into binding legal frameworks. Using the IPBES Life Framework, we code value orientations in UK and Mexican water legislation and evaluate whether each is legible in law and actionable through minimum legal viability conditions—institutional mandates, procedural decision pathways, and enforceable substantive duties or standards. Beyond the case studies, the method is replicable across jurisdictions and transferable beyond water to other nature-related legislation, enabling systematic diagnosis of feasibility gaps in the legal enactment of plural values.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7164585511
Cites: 38
Cited by:
Related to: 10