Sound sutures: Buddhism, music, and religiosity in contemporary Japan
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation rethinks representations of sound, music, and Buddhism in contemporary Japan by investigating heterogeneous, co-existing ways of sounding Buddhism in situ as well as in technologically mediated circulation. The throughline of this dissertation is a recent trend of Buddhist priests who have taken to strumming guitars, DJing, and using social media platforms in order to address challenges facing Buddhist institutions. In contemporary Japan, younger generations feel estranged from Buddhism and, more broadly, “religion” (shūkyō). Meanwhile, temples face looming financial precarity within Japan’s recessionary economy, as their core supporters grow older and pass on. Concerned priests as well as members of the nonreligious public claim that temple Buddhism has become stuck in rote forms, and has failed to attend to the concerns of younger generations, as well as problems facing Japanese society in general. This dissertation asks: how do priests use sound and music in order to address these problems? How do they negotiate, generate, and articulate tension between respect for traditionality, on the one hand, and imperatives to change and innovate, on the other? As innovative, new sounds, as well as old, traditional sounds of Buddhism reverberate beyond the walls of temples within the sphere of everyday life in secular society, how do sonic practices and technologies of mediation affect the formation of religio-spiritual sensibilities? Against a background of anglophone scholarship on Japanese Buddhist sound and music that privileges practices normatively coded as traditional while overlooking issues of technology and political economy, the innovations of priest-musicians might seem like radical departures from tradition. However, by situating these practices within a genealogy of musical and religious reforms and developments that changed the contours of Japanese religio-spiritual sensibilities as the nation modernized in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, such as the genre of praise songs (bukkyō sanka), I claim that these innovations are a contemporary iteration of a longstanding practice of modernizing Buddhism in the site of sound. Employing ethnographic methods, as well as historical and archival analysis, I investigate four aesthetically and functionally different ways of sounding Buddhism and “affectively attuning” to its teachings. By examining different ways that “Buddhism” becomes meaningful through practices of sounding and listening, this dissertation demonstrates how the modern constitution of “religion” (shūkyō) and “music” (ongaku) in Japan destabilizes and transforms practices under the category of “Buddhism,” and leads to a proliferation of affective, effective, and functional ways to negotiate religio-spiritual issues through sensory practices. Through this analysis, I contribute to the fields of ethnomusicology, Japanese religious studies, and Buddhist studies, as well as scholarship on the intersection of technology and religion. I assert the importance of attending to the ambivalence that is a corollary of modern, overdetermined categories of representation in scholarship that attends to how sonic aesthetics mediate religious experience. My central analytic of “sonic sutures” draws on Buddhist philosophy, interlocutor testimony and cultural theory in order to demonstrate ways that sound and sound-makers constantly make and unmake Buddhistic subjectivities and identities through two-sided processes of affective investment. I show how what I call “affective attunements” to various notions of a Buddhistic cosmos are produced through heterogeneous practices of sounding and listening, which overlap with other regimes of religio-spiritual as well as secular meaningfulness and efficacy. Extending beyond the disciplinary boundaries of Japan and Buddhist studies, my analytic strategies can be generalized for navigating the ambivalent relationships between technologically mediated sounds and images of religious content, and the embodied experiences of the everyday in modern societies around the world.
Source: OpenBU (Boston University)
Author: Reehl, Duncan
Language: English
Topic: Indian and Buddhist Studies
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7164789124
