The Role of Public Media in a Global Crisis: A Comparative Study of German and Chinese Public Broadcasters' Media Quality in COVID-19 Pandemic Reporting
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: During a global health crisis such as the COVID-19 pandemic, high-quality reporting is essential for informing the public about health risks, preventive measures, and public health guidelines, while misinformation can lead to confusion and reluctance to follow health guidelines. This study examines the quality of COVID-19 crisis coverage on Chinese and German public television, focusing on five core media quality norms: relevance, transparency, accuracy, diversity, and impartiality. The study uses a comparative analysis method, examining four news programs from German television NDR and DW, as well as Chinese television CGTN and SMG, from January 2020 to January 2021. Key findings reveal that German public media demonstrate a strong commitment to diversity and transparency, offering varied perspectives and citing sources to enhance credibility. They generally uphold accuracy and impartiality, although they face some constraints owing to social pressures and operational limitations. Chinese televisions prioritize relevance and accuracy when disseminating government-led pandemic measures. However, their transparency and diversity are limited. Impartiality is constrained by the focus on social stability and alignment with state policies. Both countries' media adapt their focus over time to address different stages of the pandemic. The findings suggest that effective crisis communication is shaped by the quality of journalism practiced within each media governance structure. However, it is important to note that 'quality' does not carry the same normative weight across both systems. In democratic media contexts, quality norms such as transparency, diversity, and impartiality function as professional standards that journalism can aspire to and, in principle, fulfill. In autocratic contexts, these same dimensions are structurally bounded: their ceiling is set not by journalistic capacity but by systemic constraints, including alignment with state priorities and restrictions on editorial independence. The comparative analysis thus reveals not only different quality profiles, but different conditions under which quality itself is possible.
Author: Chen, Bin
Institutions: Hochschule Hannover, Fudan University
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7164981423
