Trans eliminationism: An Ideology Escalation Framework for understanding recent trans health policies
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background Contemporary political rhetoric targeting trans people is often described with terms such as "anti-trans" and "trans exclusionary," which encompass a wide range of beliefs and political motivations. These labels encompass diverse political positions and may obscure important differences in the severity and mechanisms of harm.Aims To introduce the concept of trans eliminationism to describe political efforts to remove trans people from social, legal, conceptual, or physical existence, and to develop the Anti-trans Ideology Escalation Framework to explain how anti-trans ideologies can escalate into increasingly harmful eliminationist outcomes through specific sociocognitive mechanisms.Methods Drawing on Goldhagen’s eliminationism theory, I develop the Anti-trans Ideological Escalation Framework through conceptual and theoretical adaptation and apply it in an illustrative critical reading of two recent reviews of trans youth healthcare: the UK Cass Review and the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) report.Results The framework identifies cis supremacy and anti-trans prejudice as foundational conditions, and biological reductionism and essentialism, dehumanization, threat construction as bridging mechanisms through which prejudice escalates into eliminationism. Eliminationist outcomes are conceptualized along a continuum from social, legal, and institutional eliminationism (including administrative erasure, healthcare denial, legal restrictions, and social elimination) to incarceration and violence. Applied to the two healthcare reviews, the framework reveals qualitatively different ideological positions: the Cass Review withholds recognition of trans children as a legitimate social group—positioning them instead as provisional subjects whose identities require extended verification—and has resulted in medical elimination through the effective denial of care; while the HHS report uses biological reductionism and essentialism as definitional eliminationism, restructuring sex/gender categories in ways that make trans people become conceptually illegitimate within healthcare.Discussion Trans eliminationism reflects the activation of latent prejudice within cis supremacist social structures and intersects with other systems of oppression, meaning eliminationist harms are distributed unevenly across trans populations. Escalation toward more violent forms of eliminationism is not inevitable but requires early recognition and coordinated resistance. The Anti-trans Ideology Escalation Framework offers clinicians, policymakers, researchers, and advocates a conceptual tool for identifying eliminationist dynamics, anticipating harms, and challenging policy positions that present ideologically driven restrictions as neutral, cautious, or evidence-based.
Author: Jaimie F. Veale
Institution: University of Waikato
Language: English
Subfield: Social Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Funder: Royal Society Te Apārangi
OpenAlex ID: W7164990804