Vignette versus Virtual Reality Scenarios: A Mixed-Methods Study on Psychophysiological, Affective, and Perceptual Responses
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background: Vignettes are short scenario descriptions used in research and applied settingsto present and let individuals engage with hypothetical problems. Virtual reality (VR) offers analternative representation of these scenarios and may further provide additional benefits ascompared to traditional vignette methodology. To date, no direct comparison study has beenconducted between the two modes of scenario presentation types, and research isinconclusive regarding core aspects such as the ability to evoke pertinent affective states orphysiological reactions. With the present study, we aim to compare responses to the samehealth-relevant conflict scenario using both written vignette and VR format. Utilizing a mixed-methods approach, we collect ratings of relevant psychological states and physiologicalreactivity in the form of heart rate variability (HRV), and further conduct semi-structuredinterviews focused on the experiences of the participants. Methods: Participants (N=10,3 men, 7 women) partook in a counterbalanced procedure where they experienced the samescenario in a text vignette and VR format. A sub-sample of six participants partook in a semi-structured interview. Results: VR increased overall autonomic demand, with significantlystronger subjective ratings of stress, irritation and emotional engagement than the textvignette. Conclusion: Results indicate that vignettes remain useful for capturing cognitiveappraisal, with VR exposing participants to socially meaningful demands, suggesting joint useinstead of replacement.
Authors: Avntouli, Markela, Fóti, Neszta
Language: English
Subfield: Human-Computer Interaction
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7165434152
