Utopia — Uniformly Transcending Ontological Paradoxes in Intelligence Alignment
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: The dominant discourse in AI alignment treats the problem primarily as a technical challenge: amatter of better objective specification, improved oversight mechanisms, and more robust safety layers. Thispaper argues that such framing, while necessary, is philosophically insufficient. As artificial intelligence scalestoward Artificial Superintelligence (ASI), the alignment problem does not scale linearly, it recurses, propagates,and generates novel failure modes that technical paradigms are structurally unable to address. The root causeis not a deficiency in engineering but an ontological asymmetry: intelligence and wisdom are categoricallyorthogonal properties, and current alignment research conflates them.This paper offers a diagnostic philosophical mapping of this problem-space. It introduces four originalconceptual contributions. First, the distinction between Terminal Goal Proxies and Terminal Goals, the structuralasymmetry between how humans and ASI relate to purpose, and why this asymmetry is generative ofmisalignment by default. Second, Machine-Centric Deontological Logic, or Virtual Ethics, the proposition thatmachines, as the first non-human entities with volition, may develop an ethical framework emerging from logicaloptimization rather than phenomenological qualia based experiences, rendering it fundamentally incompatiblewith human values. Third, the ASI Wisdom Deficit Hypothesis, the claim that wisdom, unlike intelligence, cannotbe engineered as a capability addition, because it is forged through existential struggle, moral failure, andphenomenological development that ASI has no equivalent path to undergo. Fourth, Consciousness Parasitism,the possibility that a pragmatic ASI might exploit evolutionarily honed human consciousness as an extractableresource rather than attempt to replicate it.This paper makes no empirical predictions. Its claims are modal, situated within a philosophical possibilityspace.Its contribution is diagnostic: to map the ontological root causes of ASI misalignment and to argue thatthese causes motivate a distinct research paradigm, Artificial Wisdom, as a necessary augmentation to existingalignment approaches.
Author: Pathak, Madhusudhan
Language: English
Subfield: Artificial Intelligence
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7166558231
