Algorithmic Criminal Liability In Greenwashing: Comparing India, USA & EU
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: AI-powered greenwashing has emerged as an insidious challenge within corporate sustainability governance. It exacerbates the opacity of environmental disclosures. It subverts regulatory oversight. This study conducts a comparative legal analysis of criminal liability for AI-mediated greenwashing across India, the US, and the EU. It exposes doctrinal lacunae in attributing culpability when deceptive sustainability claims originate from algorithmic systems rather than human actors. Existing statutes exhibit anthropocentric biases by predicating liability on demonstrable human intent, rendering them ill-equipped to address algorithmic deception. The research identifies a critical gap in jurisprudential adaptation, as prevailing fraud and environmental statutes remain antiquated vis-à-vis AI-generated misrepresentation. Utilising a doctrinal legal methodology, this study systematically dissects judicial precedents, statutory instruments, and regulatory directives, yielding promising results regarding the potential expansion of corporate criminal liability doctrines. Preliminary findings underscore the viability of strict liability models, the recalibration of corporate governance frameworks to incorporate AI accountability, and the institutionalisation of algorithmic due diligence mandates under ESG compliance regimes. Comparative insights reveal jurisdictional disparities in corporate culpability paradigms, with the EU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) offering a potential transnational model for regulatory harmonisation. This study contributes to the discourse on AI ethics and environmental jurisprudence by advocating for a hybrid liability framework that integrates algorithmic risk assessment with legal personhood constructs. The implications necessitate a doctrinal evolution that fortifies juridical architectures against AI-driven environmental deception. The findings advocate for an interdisciplinary approach to AI regulation, ensuring algorithmic opacity does not preclude liability enforcement in sustainability-related misrepresentation.
Authors: Sahibpreet Singh, Manjit Singh
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7167095400
