Work

Getting in isn't enough : the unequal work of belonging in higher education for ethnic-cultural minorities in an open-admissions university

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation examines how ethnic-cultural minority (ECM) students make sense of their university sense of belonging (SoB) within formally open-admissions higher education (HE) systems, using Flanders as a theoretically rich case. Although the Flemish system minimises formal barriers to HE-access, inequalities persist in students’ experiences and outcomes. The introduction of this dissertation therefore argues that to understand these inequalities, attention must shift from access alone to the lived experience of HE, with SoB as a central lens. Belonging is positioned not as a “soft” or purely affective concept, but as a key mechanism shaping engagement and unequal outcomes - particularly for students navigating institutional environments where dominant norms may not align with their backgrounds. The theoretical framework conceptualises SoB as a dynamic, multidimensional, relational, and identity-linked process that is unevenly distributed across social groups. It integrates four complementary theoretical perspectives. First, Bourdieu’s cultural reproduction framework situates SoB within structural conditions, highlighting how the distribution of capital, habitus, and the institutional field shape students’ positions and possibilities for recognition. Second, symbolic interactionism emphasises the interactional and interpretative processes through which SoB is constructed in everyday encounters. Third, sociological theories of agency (Archer; Emirbayer & Mische) conceptualise SoB as both agentically constructed and temporally embedded, distinguishing between how belonging changes over time (longitudinally) and how students interpret their past, present, and future in making sense of it. By integrating these perspectives through a morphogenetic framework, the dissertation conceptualises SoB as an ongoing negotiation shaped by the interplay between structural inequalities, social interactions, and students’ reflexive meaning-making across time. This approach enables a nuanced understanding of how inequalities in HE are not only structurally produced, but also interpreted in students’ everyday lives. This dissertation adopts a longitudinal qualitative research design to examine processes of meaning-making over time. Data were generated through three waves of 69 semi-structured in-depth interviews with the same 31 participants across approximately one and a half academic years, allowing for the analysis of evolving experiences and interpretations. A purposive sampling strategy was employed to recruit first-year students with a migration background, ensuring variation in socioeconomic status (SES), academic discipline, FiF-status, religious background, etcetera. The interview design was iterative and flexible, combining a semi-structured guide with openness to participant-led themes. Across data-collection waves, the focus shifted from retrospective accounts of study choice to ongoing experiences in HE, while incorporating recursive reflection on earlier interviews. The analysis combined qualitative content analysis and reflexive thematic analysis. Content analysis was used to systematically organize the large, multi-wave dataset, while reflexive thematic analysis enabled an in-depth, interpretive engagement with patterns of meaning and change over time. A central analytical focus was the integration of temporality, examining both within-case trajectories and cross-case patterns. Rather than aiming for statistical generalization, the study pursues analytic generalization, contributing theoretically grounded insights into processes of change and meaning-making. The findings demonstrate that belonging does not begin at university entry but is already formed through prior experiences shaped by ethnicity, SES, tracking, and access to valued capital. These trajectories influence whether students see themselves as legitimate participants. Belonging then continues to develop in a temporal and non-linear way as experiences are reinterpreted over time. SoB is multidimensional but not additive. While social belonging often serves as an entry point, academic and personal domains become increasingly important. Students actively (de)prioritise these domains, assembling belonging in ways that sustain engagement even when full inclusion is absent. As such, belonging is configurational and uneven, with belonging and non-belonging often coexisting. Central to this process is meaning-making. Students continuously interpret and negotiate SoB in relation to past experiences, present contexts, and future aspirations. Anticipated futures play a key role in sustaining engagement, positioning belonging as a temporal horizon rather than a fixed state. At the same time, SoB is shaped by the interaction of agency and structure. Students actively construct belonging, but within unequal conditions. For many ECM students, this requires ongoing effort, particularly when institutional norms do not readily match their individual habitus. This highlights the politics of belonging: a normative and contested process shaped by institutional and societal power structures. Universities implicitly define who belongs, but these dynamics extend beyond HE into earlier educational and social contexts.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7167177863
Cites: 192
Cited by:
Related to: 10