Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This cumulative thesis addressed the overarching question of which theoretically and empirically grounded design principles can be derived to inform the development of digital learning environments that aim to systematically promote part-whole understanding in early mathematics education. To address this question, the thesis adopts the Design Thinking approach as an overarching methodological framework, structuring the work into a theory-driven exploration of the problem space and a theory-developing investigation of the solution space. Building on the Socio-Didactical Tetrahedron (SDT), the first part of this thesis constituted a theory-driven exploration of the problem space within the Design Thinking approach by empirically analysing the educational relevance of promoting part-whole understanding through digital apps by focusing on the students’, the teachers’, and the digital artefacts’ perspectives. As such, three studies have been conducted, with each one focusing on one of these perspectives. Addressing the students’ perspective, the first study, conducted with n = 111 first graders, explored the contribution of their part-whole understanding for solving basic addition problems, when adjusting for language, general cognitive and counting skills. The second study, which focussed on the teachers’ perspective, examined aspects influencing primary school teachers’ Information and Communication Technology (ICT) use in mathematics classes, by conducting a quantitative cross-sectional questionnaire study with n = 154 primary school mathematics teachers. Finally, addressing the digital artefacts’ perspective, the third study was a theory-driven evaluation study of current educational apps that aimed to analyse whether, and if so in which ways, systematically pre-selected apps (n = 18) provide suitable approaches to systematically promote part-whole understanding. First, the findings showed that part-whole understanding is significantly related to first graders’ addition performance and their use of non-counting-based solution strategies, beyond language, general cognitive and counting skills. Second, primary school mathematics teachers’ ICT use in class was found to significantly depend on their ICT self-efficacy and on infrastructural factors, with the majority of teachers expressing limited access to appropriate Information and Communication Technology. Third, the app analysis revealed that current educational apps are not suitable to systematically promote part-whole understanding, as they mainly focus on automating part-whole understanding. Thus, having focussed on all three perspectives of the SDT, the relevance for developing apps that systematically promote part-whole understanding became evident in several ways. First, part-whole understanding strongly predicted first graders’ addition performance and their use of non-counting-based solution strategies. Second, there is a clear need to provide teachers with accessible Information and Communication Technologies that foster their ICT use in mathematics education. Third, there is a lack of apps that systematically promote part-whole understanding. Taken together, these findings substantiate the problem space by revealing both the educational relevance of part-whole understanding and the current lack of theoretically grounded digital learning environments addressing its promotion systematically. Against this background, the second part of the thesis addresses the solution space by adopting the subsequent stages of the Design Thinking approach to develop and evaluate (Study 4) a first prototype providing a structural approach to systematically promote part-whole understanding. To do so, in several iterative cycles, theoretical and empirical insights from the first part, as well as from current educational research in this field, were translated and operationalised into a set of design principles. Subsequently, these were implemented in a first prototype which was then evaluated in a pre-/post-test intervention study, indicating high feasibility and motivation on the students’ side. Although no statistically significant post-test differences compared to the control condition were found, both groups showed substantial progress. Additionally, exploratory analyses suggested that variation in app usage and in the extent to which students systematically completed all intended number decompositions within a task set may have contributed to observed differences in students’ development across intervention classes. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that part-whole understanding constitutes a key element of early mathematical development, while its systematic, research-based promotion, particularly through digital learning environments, remains largely unrealised. Furthermore, this thesis illustrates how, based on the Design Thinking approach, a theoretically grounded app prototype to systematically promote part-whole understanding can be developed and empirically evaluated, thereby linking theory-driven problem analysis with theory-developing design work. Finally, the General Discussion (Chapter 4) not only summarises key findings and provides a critical reflection on developing a digital, rather than an analogue learning environment. It also discusses contributions of the present thesis on the conceptual, empirical and methodological level. In doing so, it provides a synthesis and exemplary operationalisation of design principles that are intended to offer theoretically grounded and transferable guidance for the development of digital learning environments for systematically promoting part-whole understanding. Thus, Chapter 4 provides an answer to the overarching question. This synthesis and operationalisation contribute to the knowledge base on how students’ part-whole understanding can be supported and, thus, provides a coherent foundation for future research and teaching practice with the aim of developing and implementing digital learning environments to systematically promote part-whole understanding.
Author: Marx, Caroline
Institution: Karlsruhe University of Education
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7167302726
