Work

Religia jako idolatria. Esej filozoficzny o nieuchronności elementów idolatrycznych w religii

Year: 2020
Type: book
Abstract: Religion as Idolatry A philosophical essay on the inevitability of idolatrous elements in religion Idolatry, or worshipping finite objects wrongly identified with God (the greatest sanctity) is one of the main dangers for every religion. It is a relatively common phenomenon, because religious people seek to make contact with the object of their worship at any cost. The result of this eagerness is creating various images of God which are supposed to make Him understandable and close; however, if God (as an absolutely transcendent being) can only be known through symbols and metaphors, then a danger arises that the images of Him created by people will overtime become the actual (and only) object of religious adoration. This is how religion becomes idolatry; instead of the cult of God (sanctity) it becomes a cult of His finite, worldly images. Other manifestations of idolatry, besides the images of God which overshadow Him, are sacred space (a place of special graces given by God), sacred time, and saints (who were graced with the privilege of interacting with God or preaching His truth). A religious institution can also become an idol, if it assumes the right to speak in His name, especially in the sense of fulfilling His will. The most vivid example is the Roman Catholic Church which assumes the right to possess all the means necessary for salvation. Citing a (God-given) power of keys to the Kingdom of God, the Roman Catholic Church actually takes over God’s prerogatives to forgive sins and grant supernatural grace. Another problem is that the Church believes in the actual presence of Christ’s body and blood in the Eucharist; under this assumption Christ’s continued presence in the world is dependent on articulating the Eucharistic formulas by authorized people. The Roman Catholic Church takes power over God and His actions in the world and thus the relationship between God and the Church changes. It is not God who makes the Church’s actions possible, but the Church enables God. The role of specific elements of Christian doctrine also changes: it is not the resurrected Christ who is the real Savior of the world, but rather the Eucharistic Christ fully controlled by the Catholic clergy. What follows is that the religious institution stops being a tool of the cult and becomes its actual object. The process of transforming religion (the cult of God as absolute sanctity) into idolatry (worshipping His finite representations) is inevitable; for if one is to know the object of their religious worship, they must create a finite image of Him. However, no symbol supposed to represent God is an accurate image, because it veils Him more than it unveils Him. This situation would not even be helped by God manifesting Himself to the one; for if He is to be recognized, He must manifest Himself using symbols that one is able to recognize. This means that He has to manifest not the way He is in his essence, but in a way legible to people. Therefore, even God who wants to manifest Himself must assume the form of a finite idol. The possibility to worship God embarks on a similar problem; the paradox of religion is that it is an attempt to worship God the way He is in His essence, however in reality it turns out to be worshipping His human images. Therefore, on one hand idolatry ruins religion (it distances one from God and drowns them in the world of finite idols), on the other – it is a necessary condition of religion (without finite images of God, He would be completely unrecognizable to people and thus it would be impossible to worship Him). Therefore, religion can only exist as idolatry. Translated by Agnieszka Ziemińska
Language: Polish
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7167677428
FWCI: 1.567
Cites:
Cited by: 7
Related to: 10