Symbolic Misalignment Without Breakdown
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Ritual objects are often approached as sites where symbolic systems stabilize in material form. Drawing on a corpus of forty-five Nguyen-period Buddhist bronze bells in Hue, this article examines a case that unsettles this assumption. Across the corpus, motifs drawn from multiple symbolic traditions recur, occupy structuring positions, and generate stable visual rhythms. Nevertheless, they do not consolidate into a coherent symbolic configuration. This lack of convergence does not coincide with instability. The bells remain in active ritual use, regulating temporal sequence without any observable effort to reconcile symbolic inconsistency. The disjunction between surface configuration and ritual function is neither marked nor corrected in practice. Through a cross-case analysis of motif frequency, positional distribution, and adjacency, the article identifies a persistent gap between condition and outcome: repetition, distribution, and proximity remain pronounced yet fail to culminate in integration. What persists instead are material arrangements that sustain ritual continuation without requiring symbolic coherence. Rather than treating this condition as incompleteness, fragmentation, or deviation, the analysis identifies a mode of operation in which efficacy is maintained without alignment. The article, therefore, shifts attention away from how symbolic systems achieve coherence in material form and toward the conditions under which ritual practice continues without requiring such coherence to emerge.
Language: English
Topic: Indian and Buddhist Studies
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7169588808
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: