Comparative Study of Sampling Methodologies and Surface Conditions for Indicators and Salmonella Pathogen Recovery in Beef Processing Facilities
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Environmental monitoring and biomapping programs are critical components of food safety systems in beef processing facilities because they identify potential sites of microbial contamination and assess the efficacy of sanitation and intervention strategies. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of various sampling methodologies for recovering microbial indicator organisms and detecting Salmonella on beef carcasses and environmental surfaces in commercial beef processing facilities. This in-plant study conducted side-by-side comparisons between traditional sponge sampling (EZ Reach™ Sponge) and wearable sampling techniques, including the MicroTally™ Mitt and MicroTally™ MicroMitt. Sampling was conducted at multiple carcass-contact and environmental locations during harvest and fabrication. Microbial indicators evaluated included aerobic counts (AC), Enterobacteriaceae (EB), and generic Escherichia coli (EC), while Salmonella presence was evaluated using prevalence-based analysis. Paired statistical comparisons evaluated differences in microbial recovery between sampling methods, and linear regression analysis assessed relationships between paired methods. A mixed-effects model was used to evaluate differences among the three sampling methods across sampling locations. Salmonella prevalence was compared between sampling methods using exact contingency table analyses. Wearable sampling tools frequently recovered higher microbial indicator counts than traditional sponge sampling in several processing locations; however, these differences were not consistently statistically significant from each evaluated areas. When all three methods were compared simultaneously, MicroMitts generally produced the highest indicator recoveries, followed by Mitts, while sponges yielded more consistent but slightly lower counts. For Salmonella, no statistically significant differences in prevalence were observed among the sampling methods. The results indicate that wearable sampling tools such as the MicroTally™ Mitt and MicroTally™ MicroMitt offer performance comparable to traditional sponge sampling for pathogen detection and provide increased sensitivity for microbial indicator recovery in specific processing environments. These findings support the adoption of alternative sampling technologies to enhance environmental monitoring and biomapping programs in beef processing facilities.
Author: Martinez, Andres Isai
Institution: Texas Tech University
Language: English
Topic: Food Safety and Hygiene
Subfield: Food Science
Domain: Life Sciences
SDG: Zero hunger
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7171271485
