أنماط التغيير الجيوحضاري: نحو إطار نظري جديد لتمييز التحولات الحضارية بين الإصلاح والتأسيس
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Why do some civilizations transform successfully through gradual institutional reform, whereas others undergo profound change only after establishing entirely new civilizational systems? Existing theories of civilizational development have explained historical transformation through economic structures, institutional evolution, cultural values, leadership, or geographical conditions. Although these approaches have significantly advanced the study of civilizations, they generally emphasize the causes of civilizational emergence, development, or decline rather than the mechanisms through which societies transition from one civilizational order to another. This paper proposes a new analytical framework, termed Geo-Civilizational Patterns of Change (GCPC), to explain why societies adopt different pathways of transformation according to the interaction between geographical environments, cultural systems, institutional structures, leadership, and historical context. Rather than treating geography as a deterministic force, the framework introduces the concept of Geo-Civilizational Potential, defined as the set of opportunities and constraints generated through the interaction between environmental conditions and human agency. Building upon this perspective, the study distinguishes between two ideal types of civilizational transformation. The first, Reformative Change, operates within an existing civilizational system by renewing its institutions while preserving its fundamental normative structure. The second, Foundational Change, seeks to establish an entirely new civilizational order based on different values, institutions, and social organization. Unlike reformative transformation, foundational change typically begins with the reconstruction of human consciousness and the formation of a new community before institutional consolidation becomes possible. To illustrate the explanatory potential of this framework, the article analyzes two Qur'anic historical models: the mission of Prophet Moses and the Prophetic migration (Hijrah) of Prophet Muhammad. These cases are examined as foundational transformations rather than merely religious narratives, emphasizing their civilizational logic of community formation, spatial relocation, and institutional development. The proposed framework is then discussed in relation to selected historical experiences, including the Meiji Restoration in Japan, the French Revolution, and Singapore's state-building experience, highlighting similarities and differences between reformative and foundational trajectories. The paper argues that civilizational transformation cannot be adequately understood through single-factor explanations. Instead, successful transformation depends on the dynamic interaction between geographical possibilities, cultural legitimacy, leadership, institutional capacity, and historical timing. By introducing the concepts of Geo-Civilizational Patterns of Change, Geo-Civilizational Potential, and Geo-Civilizational Space, this study aims to contribute a new theoretical perspective to comparative civilizational studies and to broaden contemporary debates on long-term historical change. Keywords: Geo-Civilizational Theory; Civilizational Change; Foundational Transformation; Reformative Change; Comparative Civilizations; Historical Sociology; Qur'anic Civilization; Leadership; Geography and Civilization.
Author: Sarirete, Ahmed
Language: Arabic
Topic: Islamic Studies and History
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7172229365
