Priorities for Plantation Sub-Sector Development in North Sumatera Province for the 2018-2024 Period
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: North Sumatra Province is one of Indonesia's major plantation-producing provinces, making the identification of leading commodities crucial for focusing plantation subsector development and strengthening the regional economy. This study integrates location quotient (LQ) and shift-share analysis (SSA) to assess the relative specialization and growth dynamics of six key plantation commodities: oil palm, rubber, coffee, coconut, cocoa, and tobacco in North Sumatra. Secondary production data spanning 2018–2024 were obtained from Statistics Indonesia at the provincial and national levels. LQ values were calculated to measure commodity specialization relative to national production patterns, while the SSA components National Share, Proportional Shift, and Differential Shift were decomposed to evaluate the sources of commodity growth and regional competitive dynamics. Commodities were classified using combined criteria requiring both specialization, indicated by an average LQ greater than 1, and favorable relative growth dynamics, indicated by a positive total SSA. The results reveal that oil palm consistently achieves an average LQ greater than 1 and positive SSA outcomes, thereby meeting the combined criteria as the province's sole leading commodity and demonstrating stronger specialization and growth potential than the other commodities. Rubber, coffee, coconut, cocoa, and tobacco are classified as non-leading commodities under the integrated LQ–SSA assessment, although several exhibit development prospects through targeted productivity improvements, replanting programs, and selective land expansion. The key contribution of this study is the confirmation that only oil palm consistently meets both the comparative advantage criterion, indicated by LQ > 1, and the relative growth criterion, indicated by positive total SSA, thereby providing a clearer empirical basis for provincial plantation development priorities when comparative advantages are concentrated in a single commodity. Unlike previous studies limited to commodity classification, this research interprets the structural implications of single-commodity dominance, highlights the risks of economic dependency, and formulates dual-track policy recommendations: strengthening oil palm development as the primary economic driver while implementing targeted interventions for productivity enhancement, replanting, and improved market access to increase the future competitiveness of non-leading commodities.
Authors: Indah Kartika Sandra, Rahmi Nofitasari
Institution: Universitas Satya Terra Bhinneka
Language: English
Subfield: Economics and Econometrics
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7172287792
