Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: What must law become after a revolution? Marxist legal theory struggles to answer a question it raised itself: a critique that unmasks subjective rights as reflexes of commodity exchange retains no measure for judging the degradations inflicted by revolutionary power itself. This article argues that Ernst Bloch’s Natural Law and Human Dignity contains one of the most systematic Marxist responses to this predicament, developed in the book’s neglected final chapters on subjective and objective right, penal law and the state. Reconstructing these chapters, the article reads Bloch’s natural law as a normative grammar of post-revolutionary legality: the criteria a legal order built by a revolution must satisfy to remain legitimate. Three findings organize the reconstruction. Dignity operates as a principle of non-regression, forbidding the abolition of the political subject and the revocation of guarantees won against arbitrary power. Positive law operates as a depot of the utopian surplus of past struggles, open to critique yet protected from demolition. Legitimacy demands a critical circulation between constituent emancipation and constituted law, condemning the frozen constitution and the permanent tribunal alike. A test case on press suspension shows the three criteria at work, and Bloch’s withering-away passages prove compatible with the reconstruction.
Author: Barış Aydın
Institution: Akdeniz University
Language: English
Topic: Marxism and Critical Theory
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7197039058
