Work

Factors for predicting outcome in integrative improvisational music therapy

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Background Depression and anxiety still have the questionable honor of being in first place for reasons that take working-age people on sick leave in Finland (Kansaneläkelaitos, 2025) - worldwide as many as 280 million people suffer from depression every day (World Health Organization, 2023). Integrative improvisational music therapy and other music therapy methods have been shown to be effective in the treatment of de-pression, anxiety and work-related exhaustion disorders. However, only little is known about which mechanics in particular affect the posi-tive change in music therapy (Erkkilä, et al. 2019). In this study some characteristics and features which may affect the positive effectiveness of therapy are examined with grounded theory method. Methods and data The grounded theory method was used to study what kind of characteristics and features can be recognized in integrative improvisational music therapy when 1) therapy outcome is good or when 2) therapy outcome is worse. The data consists of chosen study sample data (pur-poseful sampling) from the iMTDep-study data. iMTDep is a RCT which concentrates on the effectiveness and dynamics of music therapy in mood disorders. It is part of the Center of Excellence for Music, Mind, Body and Brain Research (MMBB), which is funded by the Academy of Finland (University of Jyväskylä 2024). Purposeful sampling was done by picking the individuals who benefit best and worst from the same chosen intervention according to outcome measures MADRS, HADS-A, KEDS and CORE-OM, which had been measured before and after a 12-session therapy process. The selection was made at a time when only some of the therapy processes for those participating in the inter-vention had been completed. Therapists’ notes, participants’ MEP-scores and initial assessment data were analyzed with GTM. First, better and worse outcome therapy processes were coded and analyzed separately, and processes were split into three phases: starting phase, middle phase and final phase. In the step of theoretical coding, the better and worse outcome therapy concept maps were compared and unified in the analysis process. A combined concept map is presented at the beginning of the results chapter. Results A model explaining the outcome-influencing factors in IIMT was created in the process of theoretical coding and writing the grounded theory. There were more common than distinguishing factors between the therapy processes which have better or worse outcome. Some distinguishing factors were nevertheless found, concerning the clients, therapists and the therapeutic collaboration. Discussion Grounded theory is a good method to use when there is not much information about the phenomena in research. It has also been proposed for creation of indigenous theories of music therapy (Daveson, 2008). Music therapy and psychotherapy have several similar characteristics in treating clients with depression, anxiety and exhaustion. Since there is more research about what makes psychotherapy effective, the results are discussed in the light of psychotherapy research, focusing on the contextual model.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7197127418
Cites: 64
Cited by:
Related to: 9