The Tension Between Assessment and Disability Inclusion : Perspectives from University Lecturers
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: As the role of Higher Education (HE) has shifted over time, students with various backgrounds and needs come to study at the institutions. This thesis explores how disabled students are both included and excluded within educational assessment process. On the one hand, social and political perspectives conceptualize disability as a social construct and reveal how HE practices have reinforced systemic ableism. On the other hand, Higher Educational Institutions (HEIs) operate under a pragmatic need to define, standardize, and assess specific abilities to meet societal demands. Following this foundational contradiction between inclusive ideal and assessment needs, this thesis addresses research question: “How do university lecturers at the University of Helsinki (UH) see, experience, and navigate disability inclusion, particularly in relation to the tension between assessment and inclusion?” by interviewing four lecturers in the Faculty of Educational Sciences and the Swedish School of Social Sciences whose research interests are close to inclusion and teaching. I utilized a purposive sample that illustrates accommodation practices of these lecturers who commit to inclusion, rather than representing the broader population of university lecturers. The interview question has been set to include university lecturers' values regarding disability inclusion and the purpose of assessment. The findings reveal that at the university level, lecturers feel individually responsible for enhancing inclusion. At the same time, they perceive that university guidelines and pedagogy courses provide foundational support. Furthermore, two main approaches to disability inclusion were identified from the interviews. The first approach focuses on removing assessment barriers, conceptualizing disability based on the social model. Here, lecturers utilize Universal Design for Learning (UDL) as a foundation and provide specific accommodations when necessary. The second approach integrates accommodations into the existing assessment structure, framing them as a right of disabled students. With this approach, standardized learning outcomes remain the goal, although lecturers perceive tensions inherent in assessment and inclusion. Additionally, the interviews provided valuable insights into systemic ableism. Lecturers make an effort not to exclude disabled students based on abilities typically required during the assessment process (e.g., strict time management). However, ableism is so deeply embedded within educational structures that determining which skills should be assessed and which should not be assessed remains a complex challenge. These findings suggest two key implications. First, what skills are assessed, why they are assessed, and how they are assessed require careful consideration in relation to the purpose of assessment and disability inclusion. Second, ecological and democratic approaches are significant, since the judgement of what skills are assessed may exclude certain groups of students and may even eventually qualify students who are not adequately prepared, while overlooking others who are.
Author: Yoshida, Rio
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7200642656
