Underspecified They Experiment 5
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: This is the fifth experiment in a series of studies examining the relationships between different uses of singular "they" in English. Singular "they" can be used as an individual's personal pronouns, we refer to this use as "personal they" ("Alex walked into the store. Then they bought some milk."). Singular "they" is also used in an underspecified form where the pronoun is used because specific information about the referent is not currently known or is not pragmatically relevant. Critically, in these cases the referent is not a person who uses they/them pronouns ("The cyclist walked into the store. Then they bought some milk."). We refer to this type of use as underspecified "they". The first experiment in this series of studies demonstrated that underspecified uses of singular "they" prime themselves, leading to further singular interpretations of "they". The second study examined the priming effects associated with personal "they" and plural "they". The priming effects were measured by examining two sets of ambiguous critical items. One set was ambiguous between a personal and a plural interpretation. The other set was ambiguous between an underspecified and a plural interpretation. The study yielded inconclusive results that may have been influenced by subjects' overt judgements about the appropriateness of personal "they". Experiment 3 pursued the same question as experiment 2 but using a different paradigm. The paradigm had subjects listen to stories and respond by clicking on images below each character. Participants were told to click on the image that the character in the story interacted with. This made the purpose of the study less obvious. Experiment 3 revealed similar priming effects for both varieties of ambiguous critical items. Priming effects were similar in size both in terms of the effect on reaction time and the effects on final interpretation in the critical items. This suggests a strong relationship between different forms of singular "they" because the priming effect was equally robust for both forms of singular "they". In Experiment 4, we used the same paradigm and the same ambiguous critical items. We changed the prime items to either represent underspecified singular "they" or plural "they". The goal was to measure the effect of priming with underspecified singular "they" on both varieties of ambiguous critical item and see if this measure also indicated a close relationship between forms of singular "they". This procedure identified a marginal interaction between priming type (underspecified/plural) and critical item type (underspecified/personal). The marginal interaction provided some evidence that exposure to underspecified singular "they" primes subjects to use underspecified singular "they" but does not prime the use of personal singular "they". In experiment 5 we aim to replicate the findings from experiment 4 but with three key changes to the design. First, we intend to use a larger sample size. Second, we will change our ambiguous critical items such that the singular target character ("cyclist" or "Alex") is always the first mentioned noun phrase, placing the character in an accessible position. Third, we fully counterbalance our ambiguous critical items by singular "they" type. This means that each item appears with both generic role characters and named individuals. We maintain the between subjects manipulation of prime sentence type. This combination of conditions results in a design with four lists.
Authors: James Kesan, Jennifer E. Arnold
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7201877997
