Public Montessorians’ Perceptions of Teacher Evaluation and Professional Growth: A Qualitative Case Study
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: School districts in the United States are increasingly adopting the Montessori approach, with an aim of boosting student achievement, diversifying student populations, and attracting families (Jor’dan, 2018). As the number of public Montessori schools in the U.S. increases, so does the number of Montessori teachers who are assessed in mandated teacher evaluation systems. This study addressed a need for research into the perceptions of public Montessori educators in the U.S. regarding teacher evaluation and professional growth, with teacher evaluation generally defined as summative teacher appraisal, and professional growth generally defined as experiences with workplace learning, both within and outside of formal evaluation systems. Research has shown that professional growth impacts teacher retention and performance (Murphy et al., 2020). However, teacher evaluation systems may not always authentically foster this professional growth (Visone, 2021), and conventional teacher appraisal models may not fully align with Montessori pedagogy (Cossentino & Brown, 2017). Using the lens of Self-Determination Theory, the researcher conducted a qualitative case study of this issue. This case study examined the perceptions of early childhood and elementary public Montessori educators in the Midwestern U.S. of their teacher evaluation systems, and their sense of how these systems impacted their professional growth. Combining semi-structured interviews with teachers and a focus group with administrators, the study employed mostly inductive data analysis, with some anticipated themes from a prior study. Six major themes emerged, including meaning, support, alignment, relatedness, competence, and autonomy, which served to identify needs of public Montessorian educators regarding professional growth.
Author: Robbins, Caroline
Institution: University of Wisconsin–River Falls
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7201935912
