Work

"El más cruel enemigo" : confederalism/federalism in the political imaginaries, from the Kingdom of Quito to Ecuador (1765-1884)

Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This report studies the conceptual history of the confederalism/federalism pair in the territories of the Kingdom of Quito and the Republic of Ecuador, between 1765 and 1884. It follows the trajectory of the concept, contextualizing its use and implication in the politics of Quito/Ecuador and encompassing it within the different voices that completed the semantic field of its political action. The report reveals the existence of a Hispanic political tradition of a federative nature prior to the political crisis of 1808, which was based on the union and agreement among the territories that made up the composite monarchy. It also demonstrates that this quasi-federal political language was the conceptual and pragmatic backbone to promote the reconstruction of Ecuador during moments of crisis. The broad semantic field and political language used by Ecuadorians offered the country a unitarian option that was neither federal nor centralized and guaranteed the imprint of local power in the construction of the national state. It has been common to think that in Quito/Ecuador the federal proposal was only important during the crisis and political reorganization initiated in 1859. However, federal-like ideas nourished the debate and sought pragmatic solutions during many crises, including the rebellion of the neighborhoods of 1765, the Ocaña Convention of 1827, the establishment of the State of Ecuador of 1830, the regeneration of 1884, among others. In this light, U.S. federalism entered the political discussion late and blended into the dominant political tradition. Although by the mid-19th century a distinction was established between the local confederal/federal tradition based on municipalism and the foreign one based on U.S. federalism, political actors used these ideas to achieve the decentralization of the state and to advance, albeit unsuccessfully, the establishment of a federal system like that of the United States. At the end of the day, U.S. federalism was not the roadmap but only a normative reference.
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7202249226
Cites: 29
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10