Bleeding hearts: missions, philanthropy, gender, and Indigenous peoples in Saskatchewan, 1880-1920
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Beginning in the 1870s, white women in Ontario and Quebec began organizing into women’s missionary societies to support Protestant missionary work at home and abroad. These groups organized the sending of female missionaries to work at Indian Residential Schools in Saskatchewan. The purpose of female missionary work was to convert ‘heathen’ children to Christianity as part of the Canadian state’s goal of ‘civilizing’ Indigenous peoples. Examining female missionaries and female supporters of missionary work as a single network explores how Anglo-Canadian women were connected to settler colonial processes. This dissertation investigates how sentimentality directed towards Indigenous peoples at residential schools and mission sites in Saskatchewan became a vehicle for expanding colonialism from 1880 to 1920. White women created an emotional culture around sentimentality which made colonialism appear as a humanitarian project on the Canadian prairies. Missionary women promised to love, care, and have compassion for Indigenous children and they expressed these sentiments to their female supporters in eastern Canada. The promises of sentimentality fused white women into a cohesive Christian emotional community which produced racial difference on the Canadian prairies. Race, gender, and religion were woven together creating the identity of the white female subject as generous and loving, and the Indigenous ‘other’ as a pitiable creature. Using diaries, letters, government records, and missionary memoirs, this study argues that as women began missionary work in Saskatchewan, they initially portrayed Indigenous peoples as ‘foreign heathens’ that they needed to convert. As settlers began pouring into Saskatchewan around the turn of the century, missionary discourse shifted and Indigenous people became ‘our Indians,’ a possessiveness rooted in paternalism and white supremacy. By centering emotion, this study draws out the tensions between the ways missionaries presented missions as benevolent, humanitarian efforts and the violence that underwrote colonialism.
Source: Mspace (University of Manitoba)
Author: Brglez, Karen
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: women missionaries, women's missionary societies, Indian residential schools, indigenous peoples, Saskatchewan, settler colonialism, sentimentality, philanthropy, gender and colonialism, race, Protestant missions, paternalism, white supremacy, civilizing mission, indigenous children, emotional culture, prairie
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7202338416
