Work

Analysis of buoyant flame propagation and curvature-strain coupling in humid hydrofluorocarbon refrigerant mixtures

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants are widely used as replacements for ozone-depleting compounds, yet many exhibit partial flammability and absorb infrared radiation in the atmosphere, motivating the search for safer alternatives. This study investigates the self-propagation of R-1234yf and two HFC blends, R-134a/R-152a and R-125/R-152a, under humid conditions using direct numerical simulations (DNS) of buoyant, radiating flames as well as using one-dimensional laminar flame calculations. The blends are formulated to match the peak unstretched laminar flame speed of R-1234yf. A finding is that although air humidity has little influence on the flame speeds of the individual components, it markedly enhances those of the blends, indicating that mixture reactivity cannot be inferred from single-component behavior or from the fluorine-to-hydrogen ratio alone. The DNS results show that the sustained burning of a spherical flame cannot be predicted from the unstretched flame speed or the equivalence ratio: rich flames remain self-propagating, whereas most lean flames extinguish despite their higher speeds. The exception, the lean R-125/R-152a flame under high humidity, maintains propagation through negative-strain-induced acceleration that counteracts positive-curvature inhibition. Analysis of the Markstein responses reveals two distinct regimes governing buoyant HFC flames: a positive-curvature-dominated regime, where curvature inhibition drives extinction, and a negative-strain-dominated regime, where strain-induced acceleration sustains burning under lean, high-humidity conditions. These findings identify curvature-strain coupling as the key mechanism controlling flame sustainability and provide a physics-based framework for assessing refrigerant fire safety. Novelty and significance statement: Previous studies have examined the effects of blend ratio and humidity on the laminar flame speed of hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerant blends, but their coupled influence under realistic conditions with radiation and buoyancy remains unclear, which is addressed in this study through DNS. It is found for the first time that humidity can markedly enhance blend reactivity even when individual blend components show little sensitivity. Further analysis of Markstein effects identifies two flame-evolution regimes, positive-curvature dominated and negative-strain dominated, linking the Markstein effects to sustained propagation and extinction behavior. The investigated refrigerant blends are widely used in practice and were employed in validating the fire-safety criterion in ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 34. Therefore, characterizing their flame propagation under realistic conditions with buoyancy, humidity, and radiation is of significant practical relevance. The novel physical insights gained in this work offer guidance for developing more physics-based fire-safety standards for next-generation HFC refrigerants.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,570
Award: G367600997
OpenAlex ID: W7203786459
FWCI:
Cites: 26
Cited by:
Related to: 10