Examining Leadership Approaches to Combat Anti-Black Racism in K-12 Urban and Suburban Public Schools in the Greater Toronto Area
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The disparities in performance, achievement, and academic outcomes between Black students and their counterparts from different racial and ethnic backgrounds have been a topic of debate in the research, practice, and policy communities for decades (Darling-Hammond, 2010; Howard, 2010). Anti-Black racism has occurred in the Canadian education system for over 160 years (Ontario College of Teachers, Professional Advisory on Anti-Black Racism, 2022). Principals in urban and suburban schools face complex institutional, cultural, and political landscapes as they strive to promote racial equity. School leadership plays a critical and often under-examined role in either perpetuating or disrupting anti-Black racism in public education. Anti-racist and culturally responsive school leaders help to disrupt the patterns of predictability that exist for Black students (Khalifa, 2016). This qualitative narrative interview study examines the practices employed by seven elementary and six secondary school principals to combat anti-Black racism in K-12 urban and suburban public schools within the Greater Toronto Area (GTA). This qualitative study enables in-depth engagement with the participants by examining their lived experiences through the lens of critical race theory. The study identifies effective antiracist leadership and justice-oriented practices to challenge dominant norms. It also examines how leaders navigate, resist, and reimagine leadership in the face of racial injustice. The participants reflected on their personal and professional experiences; decision-making on race, racism and anti-Black racism; their understanding of and how anti-Black racism is manifested in their schools; how they implemented policy and personal agency; and their engagement with the Black community. A purposeful sampling approach selected individuals with a strong interest in equity, leadership, and anti-racism. Diversity in racial identity, school demographics, and leadership tenure were considered in the selection process. Eight salient themes emerged from the analysis of this study: (1) "I realized that I had to do Something to Address it;”(2) “Supporting Students in a System that is not Built for them;” (3) “Racism is a Thing;”(4) “Mechanism that Upholds White Supremist Culture;” (5) “Oppressive Ideologies in Practices;” (6) “Developing Critical Consciousness;” (7) “The Implementation of Policy is Never Neutral;” and (8) “There will always be Distractors and Dissenters.” The findings of this study provide implications for policy, practice and future research to address the barriers that perpetuate anti-Black racism and anti-blackness in Ontario K-12 public schools. This study contributes to the body of scholarship on race and school leadership. To advance the field of critical approaches to leadership, further research is needed to examine the effectiveness of leadership practices in combating anti-Black racism in both urban and suburban contexts. Keywords: race, racism, anti-racism, anti-Black racism, anti-blackness, critical race theory, leadership.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Littlejohn, Audrey Angelia
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: school leadership, racial equity in education, Black students, principals, urban and suburban schools, critical race theory, policy implementation, critical consciousness, white supremacy, racial injustice, Greater Toronto Area, culturally responsive leadership, community involvement in education, critical pedagogy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7203959746
