Individual variability in conditioned pain modulation and alpha oscillations and their potential clinical utility for those with neuropathic pain
Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Pain is a subjective and multidimensional experience that varies between individuals. This variability may be related to an individual’s capacity to modulate their pain (as measured by conditioned pain modulation, CPM) and alpha neural oscillations in the dynamic pain connectome (DPC). Understanding these factors provides fundamental knowledge of pain and nociception that could underlie treatment outcome. My thesis goal was to investigate individual variability in CPM and alpha oscillations and their potential clinical utility in neuropathic pain. Towards this goal, I conducted three studies to 1) compare two common CPM paradigms, 2) determine whether there is a relationship between variability in alpha oscillations and CPM, and 3) determine whether CPM and alpha oscillations in individuals with neuropathic pain is related to pain relief following spinal cord stimulation treatment (SCS). Healthy individuals and those with neuropathic pain underwent resting-state magnetoencephalography to measure alpha oscillatory activity and CPM testing (heat- and pressure-based) prior to a SCS trial. CPM was evaluated as the change in pain intensity evoked by a painful test stimulus due to a painful conditioning stimulus at another body site, that can increase (facilitatory), decrease (inhibitory) or not change (noCPM) pain. The main findings are: 1) CPM was paradigm-independent (heat- versus pressure-based) in individuals with chronic pain, but was paradigm-dependent in healthy individuals, 2) Treatment-resistant individuals with neuropathic pain had abnormal pressure-based CPM, 3) Greater alpha power in the ascending nociceptive pathway and salience network was related to less pain relief following SCS, 4) In healthy individuals, greater peak alpha frequency in the thalamus was related to greater inhibitory heat-based CPM, 5) In healthy individuals using heat-based CPM, the facilitatory subgroup had greater alpha power than the inhibitory CPM subgroup in the medial prefrontal cortex, and the noCPM subgroup across the DPC. Sex or paradigm differences were found across all three studies highlighting the importance of considering these factors during personalized pain management. Overall, this thesis provides evidence for the potential clinical utility of alpha oscillation and CPM measures to assess pain modulation and predict pain relief following SCS treatment.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: El-Sayed, Rima
Institution: University of Toronto
Language: English
Subfield: Physiology (medical)
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: conditioned pain modulation, alpha oscillations, neuropathic pain, spinal cord stimulation, pain modulation, nociceptive pathways, salience network, thalamus, medial prefrontal cortex, interindividual variability, treatment outcome prediction, personalized pain management, sex differences, chronic pain
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7203962948
