Work

Undoing Science Journalism: Facing Public Distrust of Expertise in the ‘Post-Truth’ Era

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In the so-called post-truth era, significant portions of the public challenge the epistemic authority of scientists, experts, and the journalists who cover them. In repairing these divides, I believe we must critically re-examine the norms, values, and practices of journalism. To that end, this research investigates how science, health, and environmental reporters understand expertise, define their own professional roles, and respond to the challenge of public distrust. I employ a mixed-methods approach, including a critical discourse analysis of journalistic works, interviews with 32 journalists, and reflections from my own 15+ years in the industry. I find that many journalists explain distrust of expertise through technocratic narratives that emphasize the public’s supposed defects and deficiencies, i.e., their scientific illiteracy, cognitive shortcomings, or their susceptibility to disinformation, etc. In the post-2016 era, the distrustful public appears to be an uneducable one. Then, many journalists seem to be undoing science journalism as it has been traditionally understood, since they no longer share a modernist optimism in their profession’s ability to educate and inform. However, interviews with journalists also reveal disagreements about such narratives. First, although some have triumphant views of science, many see it as an imperfect tool that too often serves capitalist interests. Second, journalists are split between reporting styles that merely disseminate science and those that highlight the social and political factors that influence knowledge production. Third, many are surprisingly sympathetic to distrustful publics, acknowledging that legitimate grievances may underlie their distrust. Still, few offer a positive vision for how journalism might contribute to developing a more trusted and trustworthy science. Drawing from professional insights and from professional omissions, I argue that distrust often stems from the public’s correct perception that expertise is often wielded in ways that reinforce social inequities. In response, journalists should emphasize work that encourages the democratization and diversification of science. Therefore, I also advocate that journalists undo science journalism as it is traditionally understood—but in a different sort of way. I call for a critical science journalism that moves beyond disseminating scientific facts and moves towards debating the underlying values animating competing scientific futures.
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204015421
Cites: 373
Cited by:
Related to: 9