Work

Examining the Effects of Focused versus Unfocused Written Corrective Feedback on L2 Writing Accuracy, Error Types, and Learner Perceptions

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This dissertation investigates the differential effects of focused and unfocused written corrective feedback (WCF) on second language (L2) writing accuracy, with particular attention to error types and learner perceptions. Sixty-five upper-intermediate EFL students at an Iranian university were divided into three groups: focused WCF (n = 22), unfocused WCF (n = 21), and control (n = 22). Over three weeks, the experimental groups completed multiple persuasive writing tasks and revisions, receiving either focused or unfocused direct WCF, while the control group received none. Writing accuracy was measured through pre-, post-, and delayed post-tests, and data were analyzed using repeated-measures ANOVA and MANCOVA. The quantitative results showed that both focused and unfocused WCF groups achieved significant within-group improvement in overall and specific accuracy, whereas the control group showed no meaningful change. Between groups, both feedback conditions significantly outperformed the control group in overall accuracy at both post-test stages, with no significant difference between the focused and unfocused groups. For specific accuracy, the unfocused group showed a significant initial advantage at the immediate post-test, but this difference disappeared at the delayed post-test, where both feedback groups performed comparably and outperformed the control group. Error type also moderated feedback effectiveness. Article errors, as prototypical treatable features, showed the strongest gains: both feedback groups improved significantly, and the unfocused group performed better at the immediate post-test, although this difference did not persist. Verb tense/form errors, also treatable, showed only modest improvement, and neither feedback condition significantly outperformed the other at any test time. Prepositional errors, classified as untreatable, showed minimal or no change across groups, confirming that this category was least responsive to correction. Qualitative interviews revealed that learners generally perceived WCF as useful, though preferences varied. Successful revisions were linked to clear and explicit corrections, rule-based patterns, and memorized forms, while unsuccessful revisions were associated with cognitive overload and the complexity of untreatable errors. Learners often preferred comprehensive feedback yet acknowledged the clarity and reduced cognitive demands of focused WCF. By combining quantitative and qualitative findings, this study demonstrates how feedback scope, error treatability, and learner engagement interact in shaping WCF effectiveness, offering theoretical and pedagogical implications for L2 writing instruction. Keywords: written corrective feedback, focused feedback, unfocused feedback, L2 writing, error treatability, learner perceptions
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204016775
Cites: 165
Cited by:
Related to: 9