Work

Arvonluonti strategisen hankinnan vertaisanalyysistä globaaleissa hankintaorganisaatioissa

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The procurement domain has recently seen the emergence of platform-based peer benchmarking – centralized, anonymized data sharing between procurement organizations – yet the phenomenon has received little scholarly attention as to how these arrangements create value. This thesis addresses this gap by examining which factors and conditions enable value creation from peer benchmarking in procurement and which practical methods are used for value extraction in modern procurement practice. The study adopts an explorative qualitative design. It uses semi-structured interviews with senior procurement leaders of global corporations across multiple industries to craft a value creation model by leveraging thematic analysis. Complementary to qualitative data, it integrates a cross-disciplinary investigation of extant literature drawing from studies on procurement, benchmarking practice and dyadic information exchange between companies. The results of the interview study were synthesized to a proposal of a novel benchmark lifecycle model that elaborates on conditions and mechanisms of value creation in significant stages of a benchmark’s path to utility – benchmark design, partner selection, organizational adoption and value extraction. Its central theoretical contribution is the identification and elaboration of peer benchmarking as an activity of value co-creation between the benchmark provider and benchmarking organization, rather than a transactional product of exchange. Across each stage in the lifecycle, the depth of shared understanding, subsequent tailored offering and continuous and complementary support on organizational and practical readiness to adopt benchmarking determine the success of benchmark value creation, rather than the quality of the data, provider or technology alone. The model lays a foundation for further study on peer benchmarking as a distinct phenomenon along more traditional methods of benchmarking.
Institution: Aalto University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204019085
Cites: 39
Cited by:
Related to: 10