Work

Abstract Readability Across Knowledge Domains and Citation Impact in Forestry-Related Research

Year: 2026
Type: conference-abstract
Abstract: Classical readability formulas are widely used to evaluate academic abstracts, yet the evidence on what they register is mixed, and disciplinary differences are often invoked to explain that inconsistency. This study examines within-field variation, treating forestry-related research as a set of knowledge domains and scoring 4191 English-language Web of Science abstracts from 2008 to 2019 with four classical indices. The abstracts were consistently demanding on all four indices. The most difficult domain was forest economics, policy, governance and social dimensions, with ecology and conservation being intermediate and inventory and management not being distinguishable from tree biology and silviculture. The contrasts persisted within journals, though the distributions overlapped substantially, and most variation remained within domains. With domain and covariates being controlled, no index showed a statistically distinguishable association with normalized citation impact, and the interaction tests did not establish domain heterogeneity. Domain was modestly associated with citation impact, but readability did not account for it. The indices, therefore, register systematic differences in linguistic form across knowledge domains while giving no dependable signal of scholarly uptake. For authors and editors, such scores work best as prompts for closer reading with a domain and an audience in view, not as field-wide standards or proxies for expected citation.
Source: Forests
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,137
OpenAlex ID: W7204091474
Cites: 41
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10