Work

Navigating the automation of the arts. Values-driven resistance to extractive AI

Type: conference-paper
Abstract: This paper examines UK arts practitioners' critical navigation of narrow AI automation amid Big Tech's extractive data practices, drawing on thematic analysis of fourteen interviews and focus groups with independent artists, curators, and an arts organiser. The purpose of this ‘Patterns in Practice’ AI study was to understand the interplay of values, beliefs, and emotions on the cultural dynamics of narrow AI use by arts practitioners.Three themes emerged from this qualitative study: (1) a critical perspective on tech-driven artistic automation including scepticism toward tech-hype and complete automation of the arts, with arts practitioners prioritising human creativity and authenticity over efficiency; (2) advocacy for ethical human-machine collaboration using tactics of resistance, such as small, personal datasets and open-source tools to mitigate against discrimination, high energy usage and e-waste which largely impacts the Global Majority; (3) resolving emotional tensions (‘where the magic happens’) that arise from personal values, beliefs and emotional responses to narrow AI, often balancing joy in innovative outputs with anxiety over societal and ecological disruption.In this study, arts practitioners often experimented to subvert narrow AI tools for critical reflection on AI design, use and adoption. As immersive technologies become increasingly entangled with AI-driven creative processes, this study therefore plants the seeds for reimagining the role that immersive practices might play in confronting Big Tech digital colonialism - ie social and environmental extraction - including the discriminatory loss of cultural sovereignty and the environmental costs of data centres. A few artists mentioned that they would like to use less energy-intensive technologies and are experimenting with this, but it is not always possible.At a time of polycrisis - rising inequality, climate crisis and ecological collapse - this is a crucial intervention that is value-aligned with low-power immersive arts practices that use repairable technologies, reusable local materials and centre accessibility, care, and slow, attentive engagement with existing architectures and more-than-human environments. We therefore position independent AI arts practice as a counterbalance to the slow violence of surveillance and platform capitalism, where practitioners’ values, beliefs, and emotions reorient narrow AI use away from the profit-driven extractivism of Big Tech towards justice.Patterns in Practice was funded by UKRI-AHRC.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204367643
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10