Work

Interventional approaches to mitigate and prevent body image issues among young people at scale

Type: dissertation
Abstract: Poor body image or body dissatisfaction—experiencing negative feelings, thoughts and/or behaviours about one’s appearance (Grogan, 2022)—is a public health issue worldwide (Bornioli et al., 2019; Rodgers, Laveway, Campos, et al., 2023), common among young people (Al Sabbah et al., 2009; Martini et al., 2022), particularly girls (Lacroix et al., 2022, 2023). The evidence, much of it focused on adolescence in the Global North, has demonstrated that body dissatisfaction during this critical developmental period can have negative health effects into adulthood (Bornioli et al., 2019; Grogan, 2022; Prnjak et al., 2021). To mitigate body image concerns and knock-on health impacts, the field has focused on upskilling young people to manage appearance-related pressures. Interventions targeting established risk factors, such as appearance pressures from media (Rodgers et al., 2015), demonstrate positive small effects in the short- to medium-term (Alleva et al., 2015; Kurz et al., 2022; Kusina & Exline, 2019). Collectively, these interventions rely on in-person, expert-led delivery resulting in implementation barriers, from limited qualified staff to a lack of anonymity for the young person (Barrow & Thomas, 2022; Thomson et al., 2023). To circumvent these obstacles, researchers are innovating with digital interventions (Mahon & Seekis, 2022), meeting young people where they spend significant amounts of time (Kazdin, 2021), namely on social media and gaming platforms. While in its infancy, existing digital interventions have shown some promise (Mahon & Seekis, 2022; Matheson et al., 2022, 2023). Yet implementation at scale has its challenges such as high creation and dissemination costs and inequities in digital access (Shidhaye, 2023). Overall, despite promise, the field is falling short of generating impactful, long-lasting change at scale. Identifying and addressing causes and contributors is required. Alongside upskilling young people, we must also tackle the mechanisms perpetuating beauty culture. Interventions aiming to generate macro-environmental change, otherwise known as translational research (Julian et al., 2021), particularly at the policy and legislative level, demand more attention in the field of body image (Austin, 2016). Research-led advocacy at Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health (n.d.) provides a framework and examples of good practice relating to banning the sale of weight-loss and muscle-building supplements to minors (Austin et al., 2017, 2024; Pomeranz et al., 2015). Intervening with science-backed advocacy for policy and legislation in conjunction with evidence-based tools for young people is imperative given ongoing societal appearance pressures perpetuated across the globe.The eight publications comprising this thesis seek to demonstrate the value of tackling body dissatisfaction using varied approaches through the development and evaluation of scalable body image interventions targeted at young people and research that informs and attempts to advance public health policy. The intervention approaches presented here are contextualised through two theoretical models: the updated Medical Research Council intervention framework (Skivington et al., 2021), and the socio-ecological model of health (Kennedy et al., 2021; Sallis & Owen, 2015). Collectively, my publications advance body image research via two distinct approaches to scalability—digital interventions to upskill young people and growing an evidence base to influence policy—strategies with potential for the greatest impact, yet the most underexplored.Impact can be further accelerated with more intervention research and implementation in the Global South, where evidence is limited. The first three publications help address this gap regarding adolescents in Indonesia. As validated measures for intervention evaluation were lacking, our first step was to develop and validate appropriate tools. Publication 1 details the cultural adaptation of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule for Children; PANAS-C), belonging to a collection of psychosocial measures our team validated among this group (Garbett et al., 2024). Publication 2 details the development and planned evaluation of a social media-based video series for Indonesian adolescent girls. Publication 3 showcases the trial’s results: it was effective in reducing body dissatisfaction up to a month post-intervention, providing a scalable option.Inspired by the success of Publications 2 and 3, our work intervening via social media continued. In Publications 4 and 5, collaboration with social media influencers to deliver evidence-based body image interventions is explored. Given the novelty of this approach and ensuring good practice (NIHR, 2021), we utilised Participant Involvement (PI) of the target end users (i.e., UK adolescent girls), to share their perspectives and needs relating to influencers, vlogs, and body image. Publication 4 presents focus groups findings with 16 adolescent girls and 5 influencers. I led Publication 5, which reported on a mixed-method online survey delivered to a large, diverse sample (N = 375) to deepen our understanding of girls’ viewpoints. Both studies provided us with evidence that influencer-delivered body image vlogs would be a useful intervention for this demographic, alongside important considerations for effective intervention development surrounding the desired qualities in an influencer, highlighting the importance of PI at the earliest stages of intervention development.Emerging evidence suggests intervening earlier may be preventative in reducing body image issues later in life (Lacroix et al., 2022). The next study therefore targeted US-based children aged 9 to 13 years with a video game-based intervention embedded within the popular Roblox gaming platform. Publication 6 reports on a three-arm randomised controlled trial (RCT) with null results, providing the field with valuable lessons around working with younger cohorts in the gaming context for future research to build on.This thesis’ final two publications focus on informing policy change. Publication 7 is an invited book chapter about body image activism for the second edition of the prestigious Oxford Handbook of the Psychology of Appearance. My overarching goals were twofold: highlight the potency of evidence-based activism for policy change to mitigate sociocultural factors contributing to body dissatisfaction and inspire researchers to engage in more policy-based translational research targeting macro-environmental influences. Publication 8 illustrates early-stage research aiming to advance legislative change. Specifically, the relationship between body dissatisfaction and clothing size availability among Argentine adolescents was explored to inform the implementation of national legislation regulating sizing practices. The findings support this implementation, which will be shared with government officials. In sum, this thesis presents evidence from diverse geographical contexts illustrating high-impact pathways to reach young people at scale: digital interventions and policy-focused translational research. As a body of work, it reinforces that the public health crisis of body dissatisfaction demands innovative approaches delivered through scalable mechanisms, addressing the consequences and causes of body dissatisfaction.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204393330
Cites: 285
Cited by:
Related to: 10