Work

The Paradox of American Liberalism: Jacobite Iterations of Liberty in the Long Road to 1776

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: In most narratives of 1776, the language of liberty rises straightforwardly from Whiggism, Enlightenment philosophy, and colonial grievance.What rarely enters the frame is the political vocabulary shaped by a defeated movement inside Britain itself.My research argues that Jacobitism, conventionally dismissed as an absolutist or backward-looking cause, developed a distinctive strain of political liberalism over the long eighteenth century, particularly after its military and political failures.This defeated form of liberalism produced constitutional theories, arguments for religious toleration, and critiques of arbitrary power that traveled far beyond the exiled Stuart court.By the mid-eighteenth century, those ideas were circulating in the American colonies and helping to shape the way British Americans understood liberty, sovereignty, and resistance.For this workshop's theme, "1776 in the World", I propose a paper that reframes the Revolutionary moment by placing it alongside the overlooked intellectual afterlives of Jacobitism.The American Revolution is often treated as an ideological break from monarchical Britain, yet many of the colonists' constitutional and moral arguments echo a tradition forged long before 1776, in a movement that conceived of liberty not from a position of triumph but from the experience of loss.Jacobites of various nationalities (including Scots, English, Irish, various Europeans, and a surprising number of British American colonists) developed political languages that paralleled Lockean liberalism but surpassed in in numerous ways.They arrived at this exaggerated version of liberalism via an alternative political route.Their defeats forced them to redefine sovereignty, toleration, and property in ways that both challenged Whig orthodoxy and foreshadowed parts of the revolutionary lexicon.This paper opens a way to reconsider 1776 not only as a moment of ideological declaration and triumphant national origin, but as a moment shaped by counterhistories that rarely surface in the American memory of liberty.It aligns closely with the workshop's interest in overshadowed histories, mythmaking, and alternative genealogies of revolution.Jacobitism has long been treated as an ideological dead end.However, this paper examines its intellectual output across the Atlantic, including pamphlets, sermons, poems, political correspondence, and colonial policy, to reverse this picture.Rather than rejecting modern political ideas, many Jacobites embraced key liberal commitments such as natural liberty, contractual government, the accountability of power, and broad religious toleration.As a restoration continued to fail, many Jacobites fled to the colonies to find protection from government retribution and enact their liberal worldviews with greater freedom.The proposed paper will focus on two interlocking questions.First, how did Jacobite defeats reshape their political thought, and why did those reshaped ideas matter for the Atlantic world?Second, how did these ideas travel, through print, patronage networks, and colonial officeholders, into the environment that produced the American Revolution?To answer these, my paper creates five case studies developed in my current PhD dissertation.The first three establish the ideological content of liberal Jacobitism, itself a diverse philosophical movement.The paper will then highlight the other two case studies, most directly relevant for the 1776 framing: Sir William Keith, the Jacobite governor of Pennsylvania, and James Edward Oglethorpe, the Jacobite founder of Georgia.Keith applied a Jacobite-influenced
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204510467
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10