Forensic evidence from additive-enabled firearms and its inferential limits: a scoping review
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: This OSF project documents the development of “Forensic evidence from additive-enabled firearms and its inferential limits: a scoping review”. The associated registration, https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/ZKYJB, was submitted retrospectively on 1 July 2026, during synthesis after the searches, screening and initial charting for an earlier version of the review. It is historical documentation and must not be interpreted as prospective preregistration of the revised review. Earlier titles, the original 31 May 2026 publication cut-off and prior methodological records remain part of the review history. The revised review searched six platforms on 20 September 2026 for English-language publications first publicly available between 1 January 2016 and 31 August 2026. Fifteen candidate publications from an earlier review register were reconciled on 30 September 2026. That stage produced 70 included publications: 56 from platform searches and 14 recovered records. The scope amendment of 18 October 2026 narrowed the review to explicit firearm-related evidence and substantive, separable contextual analysis relevant to forensic examination or investigation. Five publications were withdrawn from the included corpus: four from the platform-search route and one recovered record. The final corpus comprises 65 publications: 52 from platform searches and 13 recovered records. Of 1,260 assessed references, 1,195 were excluded. The amendment of 21 September 2026 concerning ammunition-only objects and the five later withdrawals remain documented in S1 and S2. Historical selection stages are preserved rather than overwritten as if the final scope had been fixed prospectively. A source-role clarification dated 19 October 2026 distinguishes study design from contribution to the review. The final corpus comprises 24 publications contributing direct empirical evidence, nine reviews or methodological sources and 32 contextual publications. Ma et al. (2020) and Kang and Sun (2025) contribute original computational evaluations; their shared benchmark lineage does not constitute independent replication. Porlou et al. (2024) contributes an unevaluated methodological framework. Contextual contributions can include original empirical research. No inclusion decision changed in this clarification. The review maps ballistic, chemical, manufacturing-surface, structural, biological and digital evidence across fully printed, hybrid and printed-frame or receiver configurations. It records the supported forensic propositions, inferential limits, validation gaps and relationships between publications. The 65 publications are not assumed to represent 65 independent datasets. S1 and S2 accompany the article. Additional retained screening, eligibility and extraction records are available to the editor and reviewers on request during peer review and from the corresponding author on reasonable request after publication. Historical records that were not retained cannot be supplied. Third-party full texts are not redistributed unless permitted by their licences. Dated versions and amendments should be read together when following the development of the review.
Source: OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204860488
