Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Study design: Clinical Trial
Abstract: Students' success in physics depends not only on solving problems, but on constructing, justifying, and evaluating scientific claims-a process known as argumentation.However, despite its importance, argumentation itself receives comparatively little attention in curriculum design.In this study, we developed a collection of physics worksheet problems structured around the Toulmin argument pattern, a well-established framework for justifying a claim at varying degrees of sophistication.These worksheets were distributed to students throughout the semester, and we measured their effect using attitude surveys and written exam questions.We found minimal differences between the control and experimental groups following the intervention: most measured shifts in attitudes were negligible, and the inclusion of Toulmin argument elements showed little relationship to exam performance in either group.The clearest effect of the intervention was a relative increase in rebuttals among experimental-group students on an evaluative exam question, suggesting some degree of skill transfer under the right conditions.These results suggest that lightly-integrated scaffolding is not sufficient on its own to shift students' argumentation practices or attitudes, and that more explicit instruction may be necessary for lasting transfer.
Author: Mihir, Manna
Institution: University of Wisconsin–Madison
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204983757
