Validity of Tanner's self-assessment of pubertal stages in the French PELAGIE cohort study
Year: 2025
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Background Tanner scale is the reference for assessing pubertal development. Self-assessment by children or parental reporting is common in epidemiological studies but their reliability is debated. We compared these assessments to clinical evaluation (gold standard) in a French population.Methods This study used the PELAGIE mother-child cohort conducted in Brittany, France. Clinical examination of 554 children (276 girls, 278 boys) between 12.2 and 13.2 years old was performed by medical staff, to assess pubertal development (breast for girls, gonadal for boys and pubic hair for both) using Tanner stages. Children and parents completed self-assessments within the previous month, allowing two-stage selection in case of doubt. A correspondence analysis with nearest neighborhood imputed double-stage responses. Agreement with clinical assessment was measured using kappa (k).Results For gonadal development, only 29.8% of boys correctly reported their stage (k = 0.10; slight), with a strong tendency to underestimate it (63.0%). In contrast, 64.9% of girls correctly assessed breast development (k = 0.46; moderate) but often overestimated it (19.0%). For pubic hair, 52.1% of boys (k = 0.33; fair) and 60.3% of girls (k = 0.44; moderate) were accurate, though overestimation was frequent. Parental assessments followed similar trends, with gonadal (63.3%) and pubic hair (27.6% for boys, 18.2% for girls) stages underestimated, while girls’ breast development was often overestimated (22.3%).Conclusion The reliability of self-assessment pubertal stage was questionable, with potential systematic and informative errors, especially in gonadal development. Caution is needed when using or interpreting self-assessments by children or parents, and discrepancies need further investigation.
Source: HAL
Language: English
Subfield: Reproductive Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7205047967
