Improving access to comprehensive family physicians: Insights from workforce trends and policy initiatives
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: INTRODUCTION Access to primary care is associated with improved health outcomes, improved health equity, and reduced health system costs. OBJECTIVES Grounded in Penchansky and Thomas’ “5 A’s” conceptual model of access, this thesis explores the dimensions of Availability and Accommodation as they relate to comprehensive primary care in Ontario. The health workforce aspect of Availability is examined with a focus on the comprehensive family physician (FP) supply. Within Accommodation, a financial incentive for physicians to accommodate patients’ demand for access is examined. METHODS Three studies were conducted: 1) A narrative literature review examining the comprehensive FP supply and the impacts of interventions and innovations aimed at growing this workforce (2012-2022); 2) A serial cross-sectional analysis (2008, 2013, 2019) using linked health administrative datasets to examine the medical and social characteristics of patients attached to near-retirement comprehensive FPs over time, and indications of the early- and mid-career workforce’s capacity to absorb these patients; 3) A cross-sectional analysis (2013-2017) linking health administrative data to patient survey data to determine whether physician Access Bonus achievement correlates with patient-reported access in the urban context. RESULTS The comprehensive FP workforce has evolved. An increasing proportion of females comprise the workforce, fewer medical students are choosing family medicine as a specialty, and fewer FPs are practicing comprehensiveness, choosing instead to narrow their scope. A broad range of interventions and innovations aimed at growing the workforce and addressing workload have been described, though the quality of studies examining their effectiveness varies. Over time, near-retirement physicians represent a growing proportion of Ontario’s comprehensive FP workforce, and findings suggest that as these physicians retire, the remaining workforce’s capacity to absorb their patients may be insufficient. In the urban context, Access Bonus achievement correlates with patient-reported access in large settings, but less so in medium-sized settings and not at all in smaller settings, suggesting this policy may warrant a redesign. CONCLUSION Access to comprehensive FPs is essential for a functional primary care system. This thesis provides insights from workforce trends and policy initiatives that may guide efforts to improve access to primary care.
Author: Premji, Kamila
Institution: Western University
Language: English
Subfield: Family Practice
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7205060609
