Work

Intersectional Erasure of Black Girls in Ontario School Mental Health Policy: From Intervention to Resurgence, Reclaiming Identity, Joy, and Justice

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Black girls in Ontario schools navigate systems designed without them in mind. Ontario's Policy/Program Memorandum 169 (PPM 169): Student Mental Health represents the province's authoritative framework for student mental health, yet it fails to name, acknowledge, or respond to the specific mental health experiences of Black girls. This dissertation examines PPM 169 alongside supplemental provincial and board-level documents to interrogate how mental health policy constructs student well-being and what these constructions mean for Black girls' learning, belonging, and self-determination. Using an integrated methodological framework combining Critical Policy Analysis (CPA), Intersectionality-Based Policy Analysis (IBPA), and Feminist Critical Policy Analysis (FCPA), and grounded in Black feminist thought, intersectionality, deficit theory critique, and Africentric frameworks, the analysis reveals four interconnected mechanisms through which the policy systematically marginalizes Black girls: a) the medicalization and individualization of mental health; b) profound intersectional invisibilities concealed beneath universalist language; c) the constrained agency of students positioned as objects of intervention rather than as self-determining individuals; and d) the near-total absence of joy, cultural affirmation, and liberatory approaches to well-being. The study further demonstrates that equity commitments established in earlier provincial policy documents are structurally disconnected from mental health frameworks, a pattern reproduced at the school board level. The research argues that naming anti-Black racism and misogynoir explicitly within policy, centring Black girls' experiential knowledge, and committing to joy-centred, participatory, and culturally affirming approaches are not aspirational additions but essential conditions for any policy claiming to support the flourishing of all students.
Institution: Western University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7208525015
Cites: 111
Cited by:
Related to: 10