Work

Illusion or Inclusion? A Critical Analysis of Equity-Based Admission Policies in Canadian Higher Education

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Historically, higher education institutions have addressed concerns around increasing access and widening participation of Black and other racialized groups through establishing equity-based admission pathways. Ongoing social discourse and tension on the relationship between merit and equity continue to influence how equity is conceptualized and operationalized within institutional admission policies. This qualitative study critically examines the equity admission policies and strategic plans of three publicly funded Canadian higher education institutions from Alberta, Ontario, and Saskatchewan. The purpose of this study is to explore how equity, race and anti-racism principles are represented, interpreted, and translated within institutional policy contexts in Canada. Guided by Bacchi’s (2009) What is the Problem Represented to Be? (WPR) framework, incorporating Critical Race Theory and Intersectionality principles, the study analyzes how policy discourses construct and position the concepts of equity and race within institutional decision-making processes to frame access for Black and racialized students. The findings suggest that equity remains vaguely and inconsistently enacted within policy, shaped in part by socio-political influences and constraints. These inconsistencies contribute to ongoing gaps between stated institutional commitments and the implementation of equity-based admission processes. Institutions seeking to develop equity admission policies should consider frameworks and approaches that integrate intersectional and anti-racist strategies to create accountable, tangible outcomes. This study contributes to the broader discourse on equity admission processes in Canada and offers insight into how equity and race are defined, discussed, and embedded within policy norms. Keywords: equity admission policy, higher education, critical policy analysis, anti-Black racism, Critical Race Theory, Canada
Institution: Western University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7208654722
Cites: 135
Cited by:
Related to: 10