Age differences in evaluating the memory claims of others
Year: 2026
Type: study-registration
Abstract: People evaluate others' memory claims daily, yet the processes underlying these judgments remain poorly understood. This project examines whether older adults (OA) differ from younger adults (YA) in judging the accuracy of others' recognition memory. Older adults show well-documented episodic memory deficits alongside preserved crystallized skills such as semantic memory or knowledge. If evaluation ability relies on cues independent of episodic memory, instead reflecting crystallized knowledge, it may be preserved or even enhanced with age and separable from episodic memory ability. To test this, OA and YA evaluators will read recognition justifications from younger witnesses and judge their accuracy. Aim 1 compares evaluation discriminability across groups and evaluation-ROC shape against recognition-ROC shape. Aim 2 tests whether overall recognition ability, recollection ability, and metacognitive monitoring skill explain evaluation skill within and across groups. Aim 3 uses decision bootstrapping to identify the degree to which the groups rely on similar versus dissimilar words and phrases during evaluation. Together, these aims determine whether the ability to evaluate others' episodic memory is functionally separable from episodic memory ability itself.
Source: Open Science Framework
Authors: Xinran Y. Zhang, Ian Dobbins
Institution: Washington University in St. Louis
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7210289844
