DFAS-EIR Case 014: Low-Transparency Desk Rejection Following Initial Editorial Screening – Borsa Istanbul Review
Year: 2026
Type: report
Abstract: DFAS-EIR Case 014 documents and evaluates a desk rejection issued by Borsa Istanbul Review following an initial editorial screening without external peer review. The case applies the DFAS-EIR (Ethical Integrity Reporting) approach to distinguish between limited decision transparency and unethical editorial conduct. The documented evidence indicates that the journal clearly identified the screening stage and communicated its decision, but provided no manuscript-specific academic explanation for why the submission did not progress to peer review. The case is therefore classified as LTD – Low Transparency Decision and LR – Legitimate Rejection, with no evidence of misconduct, suppression, discriminatory gatekeeping, or procedural abuse. It serves as a calibration case demonstrating that limited editorial transparency should not automatically be interpreted as an ethical violation.
Author: Alaali, Hasan mohamed Husain
Institution: University of Bahrain
Language: English
Subfield: Library and Information Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7211951706
