PHILIA OS Phase 2 · 115th DOI Results Report: TextAnalyzer CH7-V5 — Structured Claim Representation and LIVE Evidence Acquisition from Base and False Claims (A/D Arm Independent Registered Exploratory Study)
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This report presents the 115th DOI of the PHILIA OS research series (Trinity AI Research Team, Konyang University), corresponding to the results of the 114th registered exploratory study (pre-registration: 10.5281/zenodo.22640355). The study applies the frozen GapH3-architecture Gap Report gate (parent SHA: cc54df0e) to a 57-item CH7 fact-verification corpus under LIVE Wikipedia evidence fetch. A arm (base claim) and D arm (false claim) were executed as fully independent OS-process runs (script SHA: c54d443e…; qwen2.5:14b, temperature=0). Study type: REGISTERED EXPLORATORY. No ESTABLISHED/NOT_ESTABLISHED verdict is declared. Key findings: (1) A arm Gap Report: gap=YES 16/57, Precision 37.5%, Recall 75.0%, Invented 0; FP 10 split into retrieval-side mismatch (5) and interpretation-side (5) failure mechanisms. (2) D arm Gap Report: gap=YES 54/57; A=NO→D=YES transition in 39/57 items. (3) Evidence divergence (O4): raw hash differs in 25/57 items, entirely attributable to claim-induced retrieval-path divergence; temporal drift = 0; dual-hash design (raw + final) separated retrieval divergence from selection divergence. (4) O0: explicit false→true auto-correction = 0/57; Step1 truth-awareness observed in 27/57 D items (21 unique). (5) DERIVED-abuse structural gap confirmed by A/D arm pairing (H_005 decisive case): Stage1b cannot detect claim-anchored derivation; A arm alone concealed this. (6) L3_NEW_A D-label invalid: claim factually true under LIVE evidence (effective D arm N=56). Pre-registration analytic violations: 0. Errata: 2 (non-verdict, documented in §8). A/D arm process isolation confirmed. Related DOIs: Pre-registration 10.5281/zenodo.22640355 (114th/Zenodo 118) · Parent confirmatory results 10.5281/zenodo.22153519 (113th/Zenodo 117).
Author: 신, 두섭
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7212067376
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: